I'm pulling a
69ron here, and not responding to a Private Message that was sent to me regarding my view of "Secret" directly. Instead, I'll post my response here.
I will keep the identity of the PMer anonymous, and note that it is not the OP, surprisingly.
The PM:
your views on secret the book and the movie my friend suggest to me you take it all to seriously and are missing the point of what is being presented , try not to hear the words and understand them however try understanding the meaning ...
try looking at this from the perspective of a metaphor rather than the literal truth my friend , sure i understand when you say that its 100 % BS , but that is because you don't understand it , its like chinese men talking sure in this case information is being presented however you don't understand the language so hardly you can interpret it .......
let me do this for you what they are saying is great people thought of things like cars , aeroplanes , technology and brought them into 3 diemensional reality by the virtue of acting their thoughts out , aeroplane was just a thought of wright brothers before we were ever flying in one , the difference is these people thought these things over and over again and second level of thought my friend is action so these people did something about those thoughts rather than just thinking about them and lazing out so WAlla here we have the possiblity of flying these days and so all the other great works of art also were once just the thought of the artists
i am an Artist so i think a picture and then draw it i think that is what the secret is telling you rather than thinking all is gonna be well so just chill and leave the thoughts to do work for you
if the above message has been offensive in any way i humbly apologise , its just how i look at things and i can be wrong , feel free to disagree however do understand the meaning of what i am saying
peace brother
life is a joke , just start laughing
It's true, I do take the points presented in Secret seriously. They make bold claims and use shoddy science to back up their ideas. The science is shoddy because it does not eliminate other variables. At best, they can find
correlation. They claim, however, to have proven
causation, and that is simply not the case. This has been recognized by countless scientists. That movie is a joke in our eyes.
However, I do not take the movie
too seriously. I am evaluating its claims. If you believe that the ideas that are presented in Secret are meant only to be a metaphor, then
you are not taking their claims serious enough. The movie (and probably the book) do not present the ideas as a metaphor. They present the ideas as
fact.
The Lie of Attraction is no more than the old saying "You can do anything if you put your mind to it!" or "You can do anything if you try hard enough!" These ideas are useful because
self-confidence and motivation are useful. They help you focus on a problem for longer, and let you enter into a situation with a positive attitude, which has scientifically (with REAL science) been proven to increase your ability to physically and mentally perform.
The Lie of Attraction, if you believe it, can create self-confidence within you and can motivate you to try things that you may not have otherwise attempted. Secret, however, attributes the increased success to the Lie of Attraction, and not to the self-confidence or motivation. It places importance where importance does not exist.
Now, if you can only create confidence and motivation within yourself by believing the Lie of Attraction, then by all means believe it! Believe whatever you want! I have strange rituals to get myself motivated and self-confident too!
But if you dare to bring your theory out of personal use and into the realm of science and critique, be prepared for a virtual ass-whooping. I do not take lightly people who try to turn science into a scam.