Maybe yours is high in elemicin. That should give it more of a nutmeg flavor I believe.

SWIM didn't like the flavor much at first, it was too much like eating a flower, but it's definitely growing on him. His oil is not as strong tasting as nutmeg, but there is definitely a slight nutmeg flavor to it. It also has a slight flavor of cloves. But the flower-like flavor is the dominant flavor in his oil.