SWIM extracts at pH 9.5 with sodium carbonate all the time and gets yields that rival those posted by others on this forum. However, SWIM uses a Soxhlet, and SWIM uses DCM as the non-polar solvent. With DCM you don't need any fancy tricks to force the DMT into it because DMT is extremely soluble in DCM, unlike naphtha, heptene, etc.
Those out there who are getting poor yield extracting at pH 9.5 are getting poor yields because they are using heptane, naphtha, or hexane as the non-polar solvent in their A/B extraction. Those solvents are very poor solvents and extractors have developed various tricks over the years to make them work better at extracting DMT such as heating the solvent, bringing the pH up to 13+ with sodium hydroxide, etc.
You really should be using ether, DCM, or chloroform. The truth is that ether, DCM, or chloroform work far better at extracting DMT (and most other alkaloids) at room temperature at pH 9.5 than hot heptane, hot hexane, or hot naphtha at pH 13. Heptane, naphtha, and hexane are just very poor solvents. DMT is almost as soluble in water as it is in heptane, naphtha, and hexane. The XlogP of DMT is very low at 2.0. This means it is better extracted in solvents with similar XlogP’s. Heptane’s XlogP is 4.3! Chloroform is 2.1, almost identical to DMT. It is THE SOLVENT FOR DMT, not heptane.
So many people are doing their extractions wrong. They are using solvents that are not appropriate and so are forced to add heat and use pH ranges that are unbelievably high just because they decided to use an inappropriate solvent.
Here are the XlogP’s of various solvents (remember DMT is 2.0, 5-MeO-DMT is 1.9):
n-Heptane: 4.3
n-Hexane: 3.8
D-Limonene: 3.7
Chloroform: 2.1
Dichloromethane (DCM): 1.5
Ether: 0.9
Ethyl methyl ketone (MEK): 0.4
Isopropyl alcohol (IPA): 0.4
Acetone: 0.2
Alcohol (ethanol): -0.1
Methyl alcohol (Methanol): -0.5
Dimethyl Sulfoxide (DMSO): -0.7
Take a look and you’ll see chloroform, ether, and DCM are all better for extracting DMT than heptane or hexane (naphtha is a generic term for mixtures of low-boiling liquid hydrocarbons and is generally a mixture of pentane, hexane, heptane, octane, etc.). SWIM’s experience shows this is definitely the case. The XlogP info is pretty accurate for this.