joedirt said:
Hyperspace Fool said:
Anyone who hasn't experienced astral projection for themselves will simply have to take the word of the projector as to the nature of their experience.
Why? If one can really astral project it would be dead simple to prove it to the person asking for the proof. Now I can understand not wanting to go sign up to prove it in a science lab, but to a very close friend or relative? Why not? Why should anyone every take anyone elses word about anything without evidence?
What I meant by this, and is kind of present in a number of my posts about this and other subjects, is
not that someone should believe in something they have no proof of, but rather that
someone else seems to believe that they have had that experience. It is no different than someone who goes out on a walk and comes back telling you about some implausible experience they had while on their walk. Unless someone cares enough about your belief or disbelief to organize proof for you, any experience they recount to you is simply their subjective anecdote.
joedirt said:
Hyperspace Fool said:
And, truth be told, anyone who has accomplished such a feat should care very little what other people think about it.
Well this I can agree with. I mean the world at large is pretty hostile to things that don't fit neatly into the 'world' view.
But how do you reconcile it with people like me? I'm pretty clearly open minded about it. I believe it may very well be possible.
I know you to be an open minded person, and if we lived nearby each other and your interest was very profound... I would consider organizing some form of test with you. This would be a favor to you, as I would have basically nothing to gain from this.
joedirt said:
However I see no reason to form yet another unfounded belief which I may eventually have to unwind mentally.
Personally I'd rather reserve judgement until I see proof from someone I trust...such as yourself...or until such time as I prove it to myself.
A wise and intelligent position to take. One that I would never discourage any person from; one that any truly critical thinker would naturally adopt IMO.
joedirt said:
To date I have had lucid dreamed a handful of times...full blown wake up in the matrix bad ass lucid dreams. Peak life experience..
Lucid dreaming is truly amazing. It can be anyway.
I would suggest to you that if you can remember a handful of times you managed to do it, it is likely that you have accomplished it at least 10 or 20x as much, as even 5% dream recall is rather a lot for most people.
You might want to work on training your dreaming abilities as you seem to appreciate how profound those experiences can be... also, developing the basic dream skills carries over into any astral projection work you might get into.
joedirt said:
I have also had sleep paralysis more times that I care to recollect in my life.
I've also heard pop sounds and sign flashes of intense light falling asleep.
Also recently I had n experience were my body fell asleep while watching TV, but I felt as though I was still sitting there watching TV...I'd guess this was probably VERY close to what is described as Astral projection. I was aware of my body asleep and I was still aware of the fact that I was watching TV...like nothing ever changed. Very strange...kinda freaked me out actually!
It sounds like you are rather close to having this experience directly for yourself... in which case, you will be able to test it on your own.
Unfortunately for all the interested Nexians, my abilities are not so profound as to be able to traverse continents reliably or track down people I have only met anonymously online. I actually believe such things might be possible. (just my belief, not a point of debate) However, from my experiences, I would gather that quite frequently one does not actually AP into this
exact world, but perhaps alternate or parallel realities, dream worlds that closely resemble this one, or any other of a myriad possible versions of this. The fact that a certain percentage of my AP experiences have either been dreams from the outset, or shifted into dreams at some point does not diminish or negate the experiences I have had that convinced me that APing is a real phenomenon (for my subjective reality anyway). APing and LDing are clearly related phenomena, and seeing that I have had success WILDing from an AP
without reentering my body... I would imagine that the borders between parallel realities, higher dimensions, dreamstates and the like are even thinner when you are not animating your flesh & bones, but flying free. (or
seeming to anyway)
I can't say what exactly is objectively real, what the true nature of our existence is, or other such profound things that I might feel I glimpse at peak moments, but for all intents and purposes lie outside of my ability to consistently ascertain. The idea that I could prove my AP experiences to another human being involves a
number of assumptions about the objective nature of our reality, the independent existence of people I encounter, and that this is not all just a dream... among other things that I can not prove or be certain of. Thus, whatever the outcome of my testing, the results will still always be somewhat questionable.
As a very regular lucid dreamer, I can tell you that I have organized a number of tests along these lines
within a dreamstate... while totally lucid, while convinced I was awake, and in various states in between. The majority of times I set out to prove something was real to someone, I wound up only proving that the entire framework we were engaged in was illusory.
I hope you understand JD, that I appreciate fully where you are coming from. I also realize that some of what I am saying here might be interpretable as a cop-out or something that a charlatan might come up with to defend outrageous claims. Such is the nature of the beast. But what it always comes back to, is that I have no real interest in influencing other people to believe
anything. It matters very little to me whether people believe in AP. Most people I meet hold significantly more dangerous and annoying beliefs about reality that seem to contradict my direct experience. That's just how it is.
Be well friend,
HF