_Trip_ said:
Last evap I have official come in at 244mg of HCL, scrapping up every little spec i could.
Yep, that is consistent with the dihydrogen salt.
We also measured the pH of the product in water at
3.55. This is acidic, and consistent with the dihydrogen salt I believe. One way of looking at the pKa situation, is that since citric acid's pKa's are 3.1, 4.7, and 6.4, a solution with pH < 2.55 is 90% H3Cit3, when pH~3.9 it is mostly H2Cit-, when pH~5.5 mostly HCit3--, and when pH > 7.4 it is 90% Cit3---. So the pH measurement of 3.55 is also consistent with the dihydrogen salt to first order (the MescalineH+ cation makes things more complicated so numbers are not exact as DWFZ mentioned).
As shroombee mentioned, his bioassays were consistent with the dihydrogen salt.
So all the evidence we have sold far is consistent with dihydrogen salt. One caveat is that the TEK dynamics may change things (e.g. not using excess citric or slowly salting with drops of CASA). I believe _Trip_ used the "drop acid" salting method while shroombee uses his quicker swirl method. In general, it is always a good idea when first trying out the product to start with lower doses before normalizing the dose up by 1/60%, just in case the dihydrogen salt doesn't form under all TEK conditions.
I believe you can salt limonene with HCl, but it must be diluted in water and salting should shoot for ~pH7, avoiding very low pH which could break down the limonene. I would wash the limonene with plain water which should pull some free base and result in a basic pH, carefully adjust the pH with HCl to ~pH6 (lower is fine I imagine, I would just avoid extremely low pH), salt with the same water (pH should go up), and repeat the process with the same water until pH stops changing when salting. Then evaporate. I have never done this, so it is theoretical, maybe someone with more limonene/HCl experience can advise.