MySmelf said:
Uncle Knucles said:
SKA said:
Let's say fellow students are laughing at you, cause you think you're at home reading this post on this forum; Does it matter? So what if they are laughhing at you. You ARE having the experience of reading this at home on your PC screen now; I would say it is real enough. Real to you. How else could you experience it? I would say that, allthough people can interpret an experience wrongly, there is no such thing as false experience.
Even if you are delusioned out of your mind right now; does it matter?
Well, that's a little preposterous. We're wired into consensus reality for very good reasons. It keeps us from stepping in front of buses while we think we're on a beach in Tahiti.
Clearly, this guy is not all that comfortable with this new way of seeing the world. It's not all that helpful to tell him that his subjective experience is the only one that matters.
Consensus reality is subjective experience! Subjective experience is the only experience we ever have so its the only one that
can matter.
When I'm having a non-lucid dream its real to me. I don't know I'm dreaming until after I wake up and realize it was a dream. During the dream "physical" events and other "people's" communicated experience confirms the consensus reality of this experience so at the time it is the only experience that matters.
We should always keep a skeptical eye on anything really strange that happens in our experience of "reality" as a possible error in our perception of reality. Until that happens all we can do is take our subjective experiences as real.
Exactly My Smelf!
You see Uncle Knucles I too have been in search of the "One, Objective Truth",
but more and more I'm starting to wonder; Is there really such a thing as consensus reality?
Sure we have a great number of commonalities in our subjective experiences, but is that really enough to prove there is an objective reality?
We people have alot of Commonalities in our Subjective experiences of Nocturnal Dreaming too, but Dreams are about as Subjective an experience as they come.
Look Kinky, we Nexians are having a massive Existential Crisis too. It's allright if it is a fascinating, joyfull and stress-free existential crisis
I was saying that the "being-laughed-at-while-tripping-monkeyballs-at-Highschool" scenario that KinkyKing described seems no Experience, and thus no Reality at all. Instead it seems to be an imagined scenario that he interprets as being real/cannot distinguish from his actual sensory experience.
If he experiences reading this topic behind his PC; then surely that is real, because it is his experience.
If he was having Actual sensory experiences of both described scenarios and couldn't tell which one was the "real" one, then indeed I reckon he would be Schizophrenic; Meaning he would be lost in an alternate Reality, truely indistinguishable from what we would call "Physical/Consensus Reality".
His condition doesn't come across schizophrenic, but does sound a little psychotic; Meaning he is lost in thoughts and scenarios of his mind's (mostly fearfull)imagination.
I have experienced this myself more than once and more than a little; There's a way out of this fearfull state of mind.
That's why, Kinky, I ask you if you can analyse the 2 scenarios( Reading this Topic and Being laughed at at school) and tell us if you can tell any obvious differences between the 2? I reckon that Reading this Topic is a very rich, detailed experience, whereas the "Goofing out at school" scenario cannot possibly be as real; Do you hear people laughing? Do you actually see a classroom around you, if only glimpses? Or is this latter scenario only a very powerfull train of thought?
It sounds like you're affraid of being stuck in a very elaborate dream or vision of your own imagination.
The only way you could be physically in 1 place, yet have a very rich, realistic experience of being at a very different place, in a very different situation would be either if you are Dreaming or if you've gone into a Coma; In either case you'll be safe in a bed.
So don't worry too much and enjoy the experience you're having the best you can.
PS:About Schizophrenia. I've lived with a severely, chronically Schizophrenic guy for quite a couple of months. Good ol' Loonybin times.
Someone who's schizophrenic is not dissociated from Reality as someone who Dreams would be, but rather experiences "Physical/Consensus Reality" + an extra added layer of "hallucinatory" Reality and is not able to distinguish the 2. They seem to be in 2 realities at once.
Allthough they may have short Dissociative episodes, Schizophrenics are not known to walk into walls or trafic.
They still percieve the Physical world, allthough distorted and "richer"(for lack of a better word)
They percieve things we, not-schizophrenic people, don't percieve, but it's not so that they do not percieve what we do percieve.
The only way people can be completely dissociated from physical reality and yet be physically active enough to walk in front of Traffic is if they took 10 blottertabs of LSD, significant doses of Deliriant drugs or extreme doses and combinations of alcohol, benzos, amphetamines and PCP.