hug46 said:
SnozzleBerry said:
hug46 said:
The Lazy sociopolitical analysis quote was in relation to Amber Lyon who, previous to her psychedelic experience, could not be accused of not being in touch with real world issues (she was a reporter).
This is precisely why I applied the term "lazy" with regards to her. There are many in our communities who may lack a nuanced understanding/analysis/critique of the sociopolitical institutions at play, she's not one of them. And, she gets media attention when she speaks, implicitly bearing a burden to not get airy fairy when talking about such important (and commonly woo woo'd) issues (and their intersections with psychedelics).
And she has also been suffering from PTSD. Give the poor girl a break and let her heal how she sees fit. I think you are going to have to get used to the fact that some people"s insights and how they react to them are not inline with yours. Which may not be such a bad thing. You can do your Che Guevara thing while Amber can represent the fluffy end of the spectrum, thereby presenting a two pronged attack on the system.
I don't understand the hostility I perceive in your post. Have I done something to upset you?
My comments had nothing to do with her healing and focused solely on the political analysis she presented in a very public way. In making a public statement, she opened herself up for critique. I'm well aware that many people's views are not in-line with mine, but that doesn't mean I have to accept their views, nor does it mean I have to avoid engaging with the points at which our views differ. In fact, I would posit that discussions over these differences are the area(s) that will foster the most interesting growth in all viewpoints involved.
I have never equated myself with Che Guevara (or any other Marxist or notable revolutionary) and again find the comment to be rife with latent hostility. I'm sorry if I've said something that upset you, but to be honest, I'm confused and somewhat hurt by the tone I am perceiving you to be using here. Could you help me understand why you are communicating in this manner?
hug46 said:
Would you say that starting a website on medicinal psychedelic education is being lazy?
When did I ever accuse her of being lazy? I labelled her sociopolitical analysis about the use of psychedelics as lazy. I did so because she has a background that allows for (and has produced) much more coherent analyses of global political situations. It seems like you are taking my critique of her statement somewhat personally and applying my words out of context.
I don't know enough about her site and her intentions to comment one way or the others. I am definitely suspicious of what it will yield, but I am hopeful it will be a positive media outlet, as it is sure to get a fair amount of attention, based on her public persona.
As to why I'm suspicious...simply put, she's new to all of this. Sure, I can appreciate and relate to having your lid blown off and feeling called to all of this. That said, the early days of my psychedelic exploration were so consumed by research that I can't fathom having been able to put together an outlet (news or otherwise) that I would look back on today and be confident that it had been as holistic and well-researched as what I could put forth now. Surely that's no reason not to try, but it is a reason I am cautiously curious to see what she will present.
We see proselytes all too frequently within psychedelic communities and ime, they tend to be those with less experience or greater desire for publicity. I'm not saying that this is always the case, nor am I saying this will be the case with her. I am simply saying that it is too early to know what this site will be, let alone to pass judgement on the site itself. I am personally much more confident in what I believe The Nexian and The Nexian news site could become, precisely because I know the people involved and their dedication to these plants and compounds.
hug46 said:
She is/was a reporter. She has seen conflict and is probably fully aware of the bigger picture. She got stressed by it. That"s what made her ill. She took ayahuasca and it helped her. Now she wants to promote it to help others. It maybe a simplified outlook but i do not see it as lazy and i really do not think that we have the right to slag her if that is as far as she goes. Maybe she is sick of the bigger picture and just wants to help others on a more personal level. Maybe the next Ghandi, Emily Davison, M L King or Huey Newton will read her site, neck some ayahuasca and save the world.
It is precisely the fact that she is/was a reporter that caused me to level my critique. The fact that she has been traumatized does not mean her words are beyond reproach nor that she can abandon cogent political analysis without expecting commentary on that deviation. We are all traumatized by the sick societies we live in. We all work to heal ourselves and overcome these abuses in various ways.
No one has "slagged" her. If we can't critique each other's viewpoints, how will we ever grow and develop new ones? A meaningful and relevant critique of her words was offered. I get that you don't like it, for some reason, but that doesn't mean it's unjustified or out of bounds, imo.
Imo, psychedelics have a lot to offer when it comes to healing traumas. They also have a lot to offer when it comes to figuring out how to find love and enjoyment in life. They even have a lot to offer when it comes to understanding the destructive systems we find ourselves coerced into. Imo, a holistic approach that weaves all of these veins together is not only what's needed, it's also what psychedelics can offer in the right set/setting.
Through this interweaving of healing, understanding, and experiential knowledge, psychedelics can offer truly catalytic moments to people who engage with them as such. Imo, we owe it to ourselves to reach for that depth of engagement. We may even owe it to the plants we're working with, but I'm hesitant to claim to know what they want out of our relationships with them.
Ultimately, I believe we should be working for the fullest engagement possible, which includes bringing our psychedelic understandings to bear in day to day life, as well as being able to productively identify and discuss our different ideological viewpoints so that we may collectively grow in our spirits and actions. For me, anything less is at odds with the lessons I have been presented with by psychedelics.