69ron said:
SWIM took PURE LSA. PURE. Then added acetaldehyde to it in water at pH 4. He mixed it for 24 hours. The effects changed completely. It formed LSH. I’m sure of it.
I don't doubt at all that the effects changed substantially. I just don't know how you can be 100% sure it was LSH and not another adduct, or a combination of adducts (based on my reasoning in my previous post)
The oucome was an effect totally unlike LSA. And guess what, it had bronchial constriction effects just like LSH does. And the effects changed from being a sedative to a stimulant. So I’m convinced it works.
SWIM did this with pure white LSA, acetaldehyde, water, citric acid, and no other chemicals in it.
I’m telling you it works. Get someone to do it with PURE WHITE LSA CRYSTALS. Do like SWIM did, and then tell me it doesn’t work. I’ll be totally shocked if it doesn’t work.
But still, LSH is unpleasant at high doses. It will never get to be popular.
I too am convinced it works, I'm just not convinced that LSH is the sole culprit, or even necessarily the primary one.
If you followed a published procedure for generating pure LSH, then I don't doubt that's what you got. But all the experimenting I've seen/done has not used acidified solutions, nor has it used pure LSA. Everyone else is talking about a coldwater extract of morning glory or woodrose seeds with mint oil added. There are a lot more ergoline alkaloids that could be forming adducts in such a preparation, and if acidification is critical to forming LSH, that's an argument against it being a major player in that sort of preparation.
Another (much more tenuous) argument against LSH being the sole (or primary) player in a minted morning glory brew is that the uncomfortable vasoconstriction is almost universally reported to be reduced among such reports, where you indicate it is exacerbated with LSH.
I wouldn't be surprised if your careful chemical experiment is doing something substantially different from the crude plant decoctions that others are talking about.
69Ron said:
If LSH isn't forming, then something else is definitely forming. The effects are completely different.
I agree. Again, I'm not denying at all that the effects are drastically different. I can personally attest to that.
It's just that, considering the evidence, I think it's more likely that something else is forming (at least in the common brewing method). Yours may be generating LSH, but it's also possible it's generating other related adduct too/instead. I don't see how that possibility can be ruled out without chemical characterization.