obliguhl said:
@SpiceGirl
Thanks for you contribution. The main reason I proposed the laserpointer idea is, that you don't have to somehow "translate" the patterns..with your graphic tablet or nintendo DS Idea, you'd have to memorize the pattern in order to draw it. I want to bypass that.
Ah, I understand - I do not think one would have to memorize if they traced it in real time as they saw it - much like a blind contour drawing. If I understand correctly they will be essentially doing the same with either method - the eyes will have to trace the object. Due to the way the eyes work, I also think the results will be rather inaccurate - requiring anti-aliasing or manual adjusting after the fact, which could be tainted by memory. The eye is rather accurate however and so it may not be that bad - but after testing around with the Wiimote and such, the 'sensor' of the eye would have to be just as accurate, and us humans really don't think on the same scale as those sensors - they are practically never reading the same value twice, fluctuations in the ground can be detected with them sitting on a table (the designer of the Sonic the Hedgehog games is actually working on a game utilizing this concept: you leave the Wiimote on the box of the game and tap different spots of the box).
Aside from that, one would have to find a way of recording the actual perceptual focus of vision of the human, which, if done, would be rather groundbreaking in and of itself - so I don't think that route will work, although it would provide 100% accuracy (up to however they perceived it).
The shifting nature as well might be difficult, although SWIM believes she could still draw some particular scenes she has seen. This is of course relying on memory. Remember also that in one sense, memory is all that we have. We are perceiving instances of reality with a slight delay from when they happen, very very slight, but still a delay and I'm pretty sure it's imperceptible to us, but the brain is mapping things - when we look at a face studies show we only need glances at two differing fixation points to fully "scan" in the understand the face for bare recognition purposes - don't have the link but I'm sure google can help there.
Don't think you will, but just incase, know I'm only trying to help see this project see the light - not trying to shoot down any dreams or anything. The laserpointer for tracing isn't a bad idea at all and can be implemented with just a camera and the laserpointer and a long aperture time if done properly. Check out instructables.com or youtube I'm sure will even have videos of people making art with this. The long aperture will capture any light and it will all end up in the photo with intensity related to duration of light (hold it in one spot or move slower and it will be stronger). Again though, while things may different for SWIY, for SWIM the nature of the patterns would be changed before a trace could really be completed - this may change when even further out, but SWIM is not even sure she'll be able to point in any shape or form when she makes it to that point!