• Members of the previous forum can retrieve their temporary password here, (login and check your PM).

As anyone tried Acetic Acid Method for harmala?

Ambrosaure

Esteemed member
Joined
Aug 18, 2025
Messages
36
Merits
1,597
So I found this method who seems to be very accessible and easy. The difficulty is the amount of salt: Acetic Acid Method Erowid

Does someone have done it? I would be interested to see some picture etc. And I also would like to knows if it worth it (ie efficient) or if I should do another method. The base/acide method was a bit too much for me, this one seems more fit to me

EDIT: I did the wrong copy/paste, here the good one:
Take rue, powder it, place it water with small amount of acetic acid (distilled vinager) bring to simmer, cool and strain, repeat at least once, on the last batch, add the strained water hot and dissolve a good quantity of non iodized salt into the water, place in fridge/freezer (watch it so it don't freeze and break your container) and cool down to really cold, brownish orange flakes will percipitate out, let set in fridge until flakes settle to bottom, pour off excess liquid, then filter the rest through a coffee filter, wash with cold salt water, dry and scrape off the powder.

This is extremely efficient and I understand is the technique used in the field to test for harmaline.

"The crushed seeds of Peganum Harmala are covered with three times their weight of water containing 30 g of acetic acid per liter of water [white vinegar is about 50g / l or 5 %]. The seeds swell as they absorb the liquid and form a thick dough which is pressed after 2-3 days. The pressed seeds are once more treated as above with twice their weight of dilute acetic acid and, after maceration, the liquid is again pressed out. To the combined liquors, sodium chloride [that's table salt, man] (100g. / liter of liquid) is added to transform the acetates of harmine and harmaline into the hydrochlorides which are insoluble in cold sodium chloride solutions and are precipitated during cooling. The supernatant liquid is siphoned off, the crystalline residue filtered with suction and redissolved in hot water.

Addition of sodium chloride to the filtered solution causes the precipitation of the hydrochlorides as a crystalline mush and this process is repeated until the hydrochlorides have acquired a yellow color (for the purposes of this newsgroup, once is enough). The final product is then recovered by filtration."


thanks!
 
Last edited:
Not wanting to dissuade you from trying that method but this one:
only requires you to buy 'Sodium carbonate' though you could also use a small amount of Caustic Soda (assuming you already have it) until you see adequate precipitation, and this is completely free from having to filter anything as you never grind the seeds.
 
Yes, this is basically performing a Manske (the salt step) without any kind of previous cleanup before. It will work, but bear in mind the end product will contain more impurities than if you had (for example) done an A/B cycle before. This is not necessarily a problem, it depends on what you want.

If looking for a lazy method, I personally find it easier to boil in acidic water, basify the liquid and decant in a very large volume of water. The result has been measured to be quite pure: Harmala extraction - unneccessary steps?
I usually do an A/B cycle first, and use ammonia as a base to not need to care about base remains in the product.

I find the "Super-Easy No-Filter Harmalas Tek" is more complex than necessary and has many more wash cycles than needed, as a consequence of not using a large enough volume for decanting. If you decant in a large volume (think a 15L steel pan, for example) you don't need all those cycles.
 
I find the "Super-Easy No-Filter Harmalas Tek" is more complex than necessary and has many more wash cycles than needed, as a consequence of not using a large enough volume for decanting. If you decant in a large volume (think a 15L steel pan, for example) you don't need all those cycles.
Just read that through, so the main difference is a big bucket dilute and rinse rather than a small jar with multiple rinses? Though the addition of freezing and thawing the seeds must still be a benefit to maximise yield.
 
Though the addition of freezing and thawing the seeds must still be a benefit to maximise yield.
I sometimes do that, yeah.

Just read that through, so the main difference is a big bucket dilute and rinse rather than a small jar with multiple rinses?
Yes, that's mostly it. I like to pour the acidic harmala liquid in a large volume of water and basify it directly with 25% ammonia. That way I find no washes are needed. The main drawback is the ammonia smell, and that a good amount of ammonia is needed.

I think talking about teks in the case of harmala extraction is a bit pointless. I see it more as a set of possible steps that can be combined in different ways depending on preferences, available material/time/etc., desired purity and yield, and other factors. It's kind of like that with DMT as well, of course, but with harmalas it's so straightforward and difficult to mess up (e.g. no goo issues).
 
(I made the wrong copy paste in my post, I just edited)

The things that make me afraid about the acidic/basify recipe is having to wash the powder and if I do it wrong it can be dangerous because of the lye... That's why this method seemed to be easier and safer. And ammonic is even more dangerous, no? Or because it's disolve away with drying?

About your recipe @blig-blug I just don't understand the step 8, decant means filter out the particuls of harmalas, right?

But okay if everyone think that the filter step make it way harder I will consider doing it the way people do it here
Sometimes a recipe seems easier than it is!

Also, I was interested in a full spectrum extraction, like the vodka tek with DMT. Does something like that exist with syrian rue?

Thanks for the fast answer!
 
So i just read the whole tutorial and I think I feel reassured. The picture help a lot
Thanks you for sharing this one!
 
And ammonic is even more dangerous, no? Or because it's disolve away with drying?
No, ammonia is not more dangerous to handle than other bases. And indeed as it's a gas it will evaporate when you dry your end product, so you have the guarantee that there's no ammonia left. The main drawback of ammonia for me is the smell, but as long as you close the container while decanting it's fine.

About your recipe @blig-blug I just don't understand the step 8, decant means filter out the particuls of harmalas, right?
Yes, you wait until they fall to the bottom of the container, forming a sandy layer. It takes over a day in a large container, but you only need to wait during that time.

But okay if everyone think that the filter step make it way harder I will consider doing it the way people do it here
Sometimes a recipe seems easier than it is!
Not necessarily. It's awful if you use crushed seeds, but as long as you use whole seeds it's not difficult. I like to boil the seeds, filter, basify, filter, acidify, and then decant. .

For your first time, maybe pick a Tek and stick to it. And once you've personally seen how easy it is you will be able to adapt it to your constraints and preferences.

Also, I was interested in a full spectrum extraction, like the vodka tek with DMT. Does something like that exist with syrian rue?
Yes, you can just brew a tea and then evaporate the water (being careful to not burn it), leaving a Syrian rue "hash" or goo.

Another option is to directly basify a concentrate tea and get the residue. It will still have many "impurities" (that is, other non harmala compounds). It's a bit less full spectrum but probably the result is much easier to handle, as it will be a powder.
 
No, ammonia is not more dangerous to handle than other bases. And indeed as it's a gas it will evaporate when you dry your end product, so you have the guarantee that there's no ammonia left. The main drawback of ammonia for me is the smell, but as long as you close the container while decanting it's fine.


Yes, you wait until they fall to the bottom of the container, forming a sandy layer. It takes over a day in a large container, but you only need to wait during that time.


Not necessarily. It's awful if you use crushed seeds, but as long as you use whole seeds it's not difficult. I like to boil the seeds, filter, basify, filter, acidify, and then decant. .

For your first time, maybe pick a Tek and stick to it. And once you've personally seen how easy it is you will be able to adapt it to your constraints and preferences.


Yes, you can just brew a tea and then evaporate the water (being careful to not burn it), leaving a Syrian rue "hash" or goo.

Another option is to directly basify a concentrate tea and get the residue. It will still have many "impurities" (that is, other non harmala compounds). It's a bit less full spectrum but probably the result is much easier to handle, as it will be a powder.
Thanks for this large answer! I think I will do the one with the picture, I feel more confortable. Plus it's 100g aka the dose I wanted to make

About the "impurities" do you know if any of others molecules have an impact into the psychedelic exprience or not at all?
 
About the "impurities" do you know if any of others molecules have an impact into the psychedelic exprience or not at all?
I don't really know, and I think it's not known. Most people agree that rue tea feels different to a pure harmala extraction, so likely yes. They also have some potential health benefits, and are dangerous for pregnant women.

As for the full spectrum experience you just have to brew it, if you're going to perform a more complex extraction I'd recommend to aim for a mostly pure harmalas extract.
 
Just to know and be sure, is that a normal color after leave it decanting a couple of hours in the fridge?
I can see some powder at the bottom but nothing very clear
I precise that I put the carbonate sodim solution until it was sand color and the color didn't more after that
Thanks!
1795190878192.jpeg
 
Here's what mine looked like with Caustic Soda rather than Sodium Carbonate
It should settle pretty well in the fridge.
 
Just to know and be sure, is that a normal color after leave it decanting a couple of hours in the fridge?
I can see some powder at the bottom but nothing very clear
I precise that I put the carbonate sodim solution until it was sand color and the color didn't more after that
Thanks!
It does not look normal, harmalas should be visible separated from liquid.
 
Back
Top Bottom