Some of the core ideas expressed here is nothing new. The impulse to see human life as central to the existence of the universe is an old and boring one. As science and reason have perpetually dismantled such ideas, the emotional response is (not surprisingly) to resort to finer and finer misinterpretations of science in order to keep on painting over the gaps in our knowledge of the universe with the same old mystical mumbo jumbo. It's getting sickening, and few scientists take these ideas very seriously, including myself. Let's take a look at a few of Robert Lanza's claims to see why.
He claims there is a staggering list of experiments that suggests life is not "an accident" of physics, but this is flat out wrong. What experiments is he talking about? Can he give some references? Chemistry, biology and physics keeps showing us to a greater and greater extent how life is "an accident" of physics, or to put it in more neutral terms; a consequence of physical laws. Exactly how life came to be on earth some three to four billion years ago, we do not know, but there is nothing to suggest it was not subject to perfectly well defined, easy set of physical laws. I suspect his claim is pulled straight out of his ass.
He claims that the laws of the universe are fine tuned for life, but this is also fallacious. First of all we don't know exactly why the physical laws are the way they are, and secondly we don't know if they have to be they way they are, or if there are many, perhaps an infinite set of variations possible in other universes (theoretical physics suggests this). That the physical laws are such that complex structures in the universe is possible, is of course undeniable. But to go from there to claim that the laws are fine tuned for us is to commit several logical fallacies at once. It is, for instance, more valid and plausible to say that we are here because the laws allows us to be, rather than to say that the laws are created so that we can be here. Life is pretty obviously fine tuned for the universe, not the other way around. Lanza got it all backwards.
Furthermore there are, shortly speaking, room for great variations in the constants of physics that have an impact on life without making life as we know it impossible. Read "The Fallacy of Fine Tuning" by phycisist Victor J. Stenger to get a thourough explanation and a long list of serious arguments for why the universe simply isn't fine tuned for us. Lanza is again pulling claims out of his ass.
He goes on to talk about for example colors and temperature to assert that these things have no reality outside your mind. There is only some partial truth to this. In the case of color, they are certainly an experiental truth, i.e a descriptive phenomena that lies outside of objective reality. No one have ever denied this. But, and here is the nail in the coffin, the physical properties of light that gives rise to the qualia of color in our mind is natural, objective characteristics of our universe. The sensory experience of color is subjective, but the properties of light giving rise to such perceptions are not. There is no foundation for the claim that the mind creates the natural phenomenon itself, but that the mind creates a representation of it.
In the same way the perception of temperature certainly varies among individual to individual, and in between different species, because it is subjective, but the property of matter that gives rise to these perceptions is objectively real; temperature is determined by the average kinetic energy of the molecules of matter - it's nothing subjective about that.
Let's for the sake of argument talk about something else that he doesn't spesifically mention, but that his logic would encompass. Take, for instance, the whole of our physical laws. What we read on the paper is certainly explanatory models, and subjective to our species in that way, but the models themselves represents something that is not dependent on subjective perceptions. Newtons second law of mechanics, F = ma or equivalently F = dp/dt, is not a subjective consideration; it is not open for guesses either between humans or species. The matter of fact is that Newtons laws follow directly from the conservation of momentum, which is a direct result of translation symmetry and rotation symmetry - i.e, the laws of physics is independent of who is observing from where (Noethers theorem). This is called point-of-view invariance by many physicists. Now of course you may say that the formulation of physical laws are made by us and are subjective in this way, but what the laws tries to describe is still completely independent and free from the human mind. Our experience of natural laws can very well vary, but not the laws themselves. If they did, reproduction of experiments and peer review - two very important tools of science - would be rendered meaningless.
When it comes to all of this quantum woo woo that he advocates I have already made extensive commentary in other threads before, and I honestly don't have time to get into it again tonight (and this post is long enough already). But for some stuff to read I can refer you to some articles;
http://web.archive.org/w...FLB-311/aflb311m387.pdf
Quantum Quackery | Skeptical Inquirer
http://www.colorado.edu/...uantumConsciousness.pdf
And a splendid quote by Victor J. Stenger;
"
The overwhelming weight of evidence, from seven decades of experimentation, shows not a hint of a violation of reductionist, local, discrete, nonsuperluminal, non-holistic relativity and quantum mechanics - with no fundamental involvement of human consciousness other than in our own subjective perception of whatever reality is out there. Of course our thinking processes have a strong influence on what we perceive. But to say that what we perceive therefore determines, or even controls, what is out there is without rational foundation. The world would be a far different place for all of us if it was just all in our heads - if we really could make our own reality as the New Agers believe. The fact that the world rarely is what we want it to be is the best evidence that we have little to say about it. The myth of quantum consciousness should take its place along with gods, unicorns, and dragons as yet another product of the fantasies of people unwilling to accept what science, reason, and their own eyes tell them about the world."
I don't have time to go into more right now, except to say that the approach of biocentrism doesn't provide any new information about the nature of consciousness, and relies on ignoring recent advances in understanding consciousness from a scientific perspective. It just doesn't provide us with anything. And for reasons argued above, among others, it doesn't hold up to scientific scrutiny. I would stay clear from Lanza, Chopra & co. and perform some real science instead, because they are some goddamned cheeks :twisted: