This is an interesting question, and having reviewed virtually all of the relevant literature I think I'm equipped to give it a fair treatment. I'll try to be thorough but succinct.
The risk of developing schizophrenia as a result of using
Salvia divinorum is probably not very great.
Consider how many young people (the group most at-risk for developing schizophrenia) have tried the drug. From the 2006 National Survey on Drug Use and Health data, 2% of people aged 18-25 have tried it (SAMHSA 2008). Figures from surveys conducted at two large public universities in 2008 put the number much higher, ranging from 4.5% (Lange
et al. 2008) to 6.5% (Khey
et al. 2008). If there were a significant link between
S. divinorum and schizophrenia, we could expect to find an ample number of case reports in the literature... but instead we find only two of note.
In one case, the condition did not seem to improve with time, exhibiting no improvement over the course of four months; the authors of this case report suspect the individual was genetically predisposed to schizophrenia, although he had no personal or family history of psychiatric abnormalities (Przekop & Lee 2009). In the other, the individual had unknowingly smoked the plant (someone loaded a bowl and told her it was cannabis); her condition returned to normal over the course of several weeks, and quite possibly would have improved sooner had it not been for some arguably counterproductive psychiatric intervention (Paulzen & Gründer 2008). There is also a report of an individual with a history of psychiatric issues smoking cannabis and experiencing a three-day episode of schizotypal behavior accompanied by intense and frequent déjà vu. The author mentions that the patient had smoked
S. divinorum some months prior to the incident, but only to speculate that there might be some relation between the patient's déjà vu and his past consumption of
S. divinorum; they do not believe it to have played any causal role in the onset of the episode (Singh 2007).
In light of this, I think we can safely presume that, at worst,
S. divinorum is no more likely to trigger persistent schizophrenia than any other powerful mind-altering experience.
I suspect many of the warnings you read were not founded on an examination of the literature, but it's possible they might have been hearkening to warning statements that some Mazatecs have made about the plant. Daniel Siebert has mentioned that the Mazatecs believe you can go "completely mad" if you don't follow the proper rituals (Ball 2008). Bret Blosser's Mazatec friends told him that if you don't abstain from sex for several days prior to a ceremony, you might go crazy at the next ceremony (this was in reference both to
S. divinorum and to psilocybian mushrooms) (Blosser 2003). The
curandero who Jerry Valdés consulted told him that breaking from a prescribed
dieta could make one crazy (Valdés
et al. 1983). An American journalist for
Gentlemen's Quarterly magazine spoke of a young
curandero who would not perform a ceremony with the leaves, explaining that a young shaman taking the drug will drive himself crazy; on being told of American youth using the leaves he warned that they would "make their minds blind" and that it would "turn them into fools" (Ketcham 2007). Kathleen Harrison has mentioned that the Mazatecs prefer mushrooms because they know they will always come back, while with
S. divinorum they are never sure (Harrison 2008). It's difficult to know whether these warnings are predominantly allegorical, serving to promote proper respect for the plant, or if they are actually speaking to the possibility of real adverse outcomes.
And on the subject of persistent adverse psychological outcomes, I think that the association between
S. divinorum and derealization/depersonalization phenomena deserves a mention. Many people who have tried the drug can relate to having some residual feelings of unreality that may last for a matter of minutes or hours after the acute effects have worn off. From reading entheogen-related forums over the years, I recall encountering some reports of these feelings persisting for a few days after the experience. But during the course of my research on the plant, I was startled to find a significant number of reports from people who had experienced derealization or depersonalization that persisted for months or years; for those individuals who were so affected, this had a significant detrimental impact on their ability to lead normal lives. While this is very rare outcome, there are certainly more reports of this kind than of schizophrenia induced by
S. divinorum. In lieu of a lengthy digression, I'll simply conclude by linking to a thread where I've treated that subject in some detail:
Salvia divinorum and depersonalization/derealization
Sources Cited
- Ball, M.W. 2008. Salvia Divinorum [sic] from A-Z with Daniel Siebert, Part 1. The Entheogenic Evolution. Podcast audio program. PodOmatic, Inc., San Francisco, CA. 20 Nov 2008.
- Blosser, B. 2003. Lessons in the use of Mazatec psychoactive plants. Accessed 10 Feb 2011 from http://www.sagewisdom.org/lessons.html. Page created Feb 2003. Original date of composition unknown; the work appears not to have been previously published.
- Harrison, K. 2008. Spirit in nature: Psychedelic plants and mushrooms through native eyes. Lecture delivered 22 Mar 2008 at the World Psychedelic Forum in Basel, Switzerland.
- Ketcham, C. 2007. Under the spell of the magic mint. Gentlemen's Quarterly June 2007: 208-212.
- Khey, D.N., B.L. Miller, and O.H. Griffin III. 2008. Salvia divinorum use among a college student sample. Journal of Drug Education 38(3): 297-306.
- Lange, J.E., M.B. Reed, J.M. Ketchie Croff, and J.D. Clapp. 2008. College student use of Salvia divinorum. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 94: 263-266.
- Paulzen, M., and G. Gründer. 2008. Toxic psychosis after intake of the hallucinogen salvinorin A. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 69(9): 1501-1502.
- Przekop, P., and T. Lee. 2009. Persistent psychosis associated with Salvia divinorum use. American Journal of Psychiatry 166(7): 832.
- SAMHSA. 2008. The NSDUH Report: Use of Specific Hallucinogens: 2006. Rockville, MD.
- Singh, S. 2007. Adolescent salvia substance abuse. Addiction 102(5): 823-824.
- Valdés III, L.J., J.L. Díaz, and A.G. Paul. 1983. Ethnopharmacology of Ska María Pastora (Salvia divinorum, Epling and Játiva-M.). Journal of Ethnopharmacology 7(3): 287-312.