fairbanks
"Our entire much-praised technological progress, a
..yeah fairbanks! we're the stupid mental-virus infected monkeys who put the system out of homeostasis..
Sure... civilized and domestic peoples have a mental virus, but the "system" of nature wasn't homeostatic before us and won't be after us. You need to get out of that systems theory view to describe nature, it's not based on reality besides inside of computers. Computers are self-regulating and homeostatic, nature is dynamic.
your idea of a 'perfect' system is the mechanistic view..
WHERE did I present my idea of a perfect system? I'm against systems theory views on nature. The Gaian hypothesis as well as the beginning of western ecology was based on this mechanical perfect view of nature. Go look at the history of the word 'ecosystem' invented by Arthur Tansley who extrapolated on Freud's idea that the brain was an electrical machine. Tansley thought he could apply this to all of nature so he called it the 'ecosystem'. So actually the whole history of western ecology is a mechanistic view on the world my friend.
lighten up!Drool
If anybody needs to lighten up, it is the Gaian theorists. You and Phyllode described Gaian's best,"Protect thyself from the Passover. Gaia doesn't like Them." "why should 'Gaia' care about You..or Us humans". If that isn't the most annoying dark pessimism then I don't know what is...You're no better than the fanatical religious right, the only difference is you are pretentious about environmentalism. Not to mention the fact that you separate the world from us. We are apart of the world, and 'Gaia' isn't punishing 'us', we are punishing ourselves.
SnozzleBerry said:See: Deep Ecology
Some of the most notable ecologists/environmentalists/anti-industrialists ascribe to models that mesh quite nicely with Lovelock's.
How are you proving anything by linking to the deep ecology wiki that hardly even mentions Gaian hypothesis? Who are all these noble ecologists that mesh with Lovelock? Have you actually studied ecology or did you just read up a little on the "deep ecology" wiki?
Contemporary ecology says that the environment is dynamic and unpredictable. The Gaian hypothesis and ecologists from the 50s and 60s believed that the environment is a predictable machine that self regulates and is always striving for balance. If you actually look into Lovelock, Gaian hypothesis history, and 50s-60s ecological history, you will find it's connection to cybernetics and computer systems theory. Daniel Botkin did a study out in Isle Royale in Lake Superior on moose and wolf populations to see if their 'ecosystem' was predictable and self-regulating like Gaian's assume, and in fact found the opposite that there was constant change in dominance of wolf to moose to flora population, it was all in a state of dynamic unpredictability.
It doesn't take more than a few months studying nature to find that it isn't this perfect little machine, it is very complex and dynamic. Western ecology up until recently has had a simplified view of nature that only sees it as a closed system unaffected by causality. Gaian and cybernetic/systems theory views on nature have never been proven in actual studies on nature, but only on studies of COMPUTER MODELS of nature.
Also, your presentation of "indigenous culture" as a uniform (or at least singular) entity is absurd. "Appropriating" from a non-existent entity is impossible.
How did I present indigenous culture as uniform? The Gaian hypothesis is the one appropriating and turning indigenous spirituality and greek mythology into uniform as smoke and mirrors for the reality that their theory is based on cybernetic computer system theory.
Again, here is a documentary from BBC Adam Curtis about the influence on cybernetics in ecology: All Watched Over By Machines of Loving Grace Part 1 is about economy and cybernetics so you can skip that, but part 2 is on ecology and "shows how our modern scientific idea of nature, the self-regulating ecosystem, is actually a machine fantasy. It has little to do with the real complexity of nature. It is based on cybernetic ideas that were projected on to nature in the 1950s by ambitious scientists. A static machine theory of order that sees humans, and everything else on the planet, as components – cogs – in a system. But in an age disillusioned with politics, the self-regulating ecosystem has become the model for utopian ideas of human ‘self-organizing networks’ – dreams of new ways of organising societies without leaders, as in the Facebook and Twitter revolutions, and in global visions of connectivity like the Gaia theory. This powerful idea emerged out of the hippie communes in America in the 1960s, and from counterculture computer scientists who believed that global webs of computers could liberate the world. But, at the very moment this was happening, the science of ecology discovered that the theory of the self-regulating ecosystem wasn’t true. Instead they found that nature was really dynamic and constantly changing in unpredictable ways. But the dream of the self-organizing network had by now captured our imaginations – because it offered an alternative to the dangerous and discredited ideas of politics."

