A high dose of mushrooms put me in a very similar space to DMT, and is my favourite teacher plant/chemical experience I have so far encountered...only much softer, warmer and friendlier than the 'unrelenting, ferocious, beautiful terror' of a pure DMT flash...interesting ohayhoco that this is the opposite of your experience (but we are all individuals and react differently to these things I guess). I think DMT use has made me, if anything, slightly more sensitive to the visual aspects of mushrooms.
Cubensis mushrooms are actually, weight for weight, some of the least potent/visual mushrooms going...its just they are so damn easy to grow. However they can be unreliable in terms of the experience they provide, in terms of potency (don't retain potency well when dried), and some people tend to get more physical and mental side effects than with other species...compared to thers I have tried, I would say cubensis give quite a muddy, cloudy high...
Very different to cubensis is the much more potent Hawaiian Copelandia cyanescens...my favourite species so far...gives a very powerful, visionary, 'tropical' colourful experience...very crystalline and clear, clean and lucid...straight to the point. Despite their potency, I have never had a weird experience with these...cubensis can be a bit darker and more unpredictable, and can sometimes really get their tendrils into the emotional centres of your brain. The only time I have encountered one of the infamous entities, and encontered a state very much akin to nirvana, has been on these mushrooms.
Other good species include Psilocybe semilanceata (native here in the UK, so you can pick your own), and ones I have yet to try...Psilocybe mexicana, P. azurescens and P. cyanescens. And with mushrooms, I have definitely found (where feasible) fresh is best. 8)
But they certainly aren't for eveyone...some people just don't click with the fungus.