Les Claypool is a living legend to me. He doesn't even try that hard when comes to playing music, his creativity is pouring out of him. Very much aware of the sea of mediocre pablum and downright horrible music out there.soulfood said:So you'd be very aware that there are countless bands who perform "easy one-size-fits-all seen it, done it's grandmother and blew my nose on her t-shirt" music?
It just seems strange to call out on electronic music, especially when there's so much awful pop/rock/jazz out there, as if you were making it seem like this is an issue exclusive to electric stuff.
verse/chorus/verse/chorus/verse/middle8/chorusx2 2nd time round with cheesey vocal ad libs, lyrics about some prick-tease, scissored and auto-tuned, fixed in the mix, ass in the video, tits on the cover, $100,000,000 later.. isn't anyone sick of this yet?
Of course, there are many takes on what electronic music really means. It could mean nearly all music that isn't completely acoustic in nature... but even microphones are an electronic instrument, so who can say. When I started out making electronic music, there were no sequencers and the synthesizers were mostly analog. Music that had the title of electronic music was very different than what the term refers to today. Pink Floyd, for example was considered an electronic music act in that time... now they are obviously a rock band



A person that doesnt know at all how to sing or play the guitar cannot go in front of thousands of people and fake it while everybody enjoys. Maybe they can get produced in the studio in a way that fakes it but that will take a lot of work behind it. With electronic music someone with 0 talent could go on stage and dj while most people enjoy and think its 'good'.. Do you not agree?



Many producers are also DJs, and many DJ's put out albums of original material. This is especially so in some genres of electronic music like Ibiza or Goa. (both of which I generally enjoy).Ambivalent said:Yea, i completely agree with the circumstances of the given example. However to compare a Dj who is only presenting the music, not playing it...and artist who is doing it from scratch..its just not right.
edit : I think its really more suitable to compare dj with another dj, simply because its another field of work.There is no music creation in dj ing. All the notes are already played. There is totally different skills involved here.
I still count one of the most pivotal moments of my life as a musician is when I first listened to Primus really stoned ("Jerry was a race car driver" to be precise). I have never heard music with such depth and since that night many moons ago, I have never listened to music the same again. Even when sober, music has much more depth and detail (though still not as much as when I'm enjoying a nice cannabinoid high).Many producers are also DJs, and many DJ's put out albums of original material. This is especially so in some genres of electronic music like Ibiza or Goa. (both of which I generally enjoy).
I am a big fan of psy-trance artists. So I don't want to get into the "is electronic music good" debate as I think most of us agree on this.
The talentless part of what endlessness & I have said arises primarily in music producers who use (almost exclusively) loops and samples that they didn't compose, and which they don't even bother to alter in any way. They take the basic loops and plug them into their songs without changing the pitch, the tempo, the sound or anything at all. They don't even really layer loops to create dynamics.
The music can still sound great, but it is not impressive to a fellow producer or musician. As endlessness says, it takes years of dedication to master an instrument (synths included)... but cutting & pasting pre-made loops can be done with no practice whatsoever within a half hour of opening a DAW for the very first time.
[YOUTUBE]
)Is this sarcasm? I am sure every music fan can name hundreds of examples of utter uncreative crap that is on major labels. In fact, when it comes to electronica, major labels tend to be clueless about what is good and who is hot. A majority of the really good stuff is on indie labels, IMO.ambivalant said:Im sorry but this kind of talentless music is never published officially, only self promoted...and that is all the credit they will get, ever...believe me !! And it is the case with any other genre...not only electronic music.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Doesn't change the fact that I can hear loops from producer packs I am very familiar with being used unaltered... not even compressed. Just looped.DeMenTed said:I think another point that HF and endlessness are missing is the fact that it isn't just the music that is psychedelic, it's the ambience or atmosphere that is created by the writer/producer. He has to get the music and environment absolutely correct or neither will sound right. You can't get the good sound that is talked about by being a noob producer doing it in your bedroom with hi-fi speakers, trust me ive tried)
Getting your reverb and compression right is an artform in itself. There's just too many things that you whitewashed hyperspace fool and i think that's what slightly annoyed folk. Peace





Hyperspace Fool said:Is this sarcasm? I am sure every music fan can name hundreds of examples of utter uncreative crap that is on major labels. In fact, when it comes to electronica, major labels tend to be clueless about what is good and who is hot. A majority of the really good stuff is on indie labels, IMO.ambivalant said:Im sorry but this kind of talentless music is never published officially, only self promoted...and that is all the credit they will get, ever...believe me !! And it is the case with any other genre...not only electronic music.
The talentless part of what endlessness & I have said arises primarily in music producers who use (almost exclusively) loops and samples that they didn't compose, and which they don't even bother to alter in any way. They take the basic loops and plug them into their songs without changing the pitch, the tempo, the sound or anything at all. They don't even really layer loops to create dynamics.