Whatever the case, that's the leaf I'd love everyone to try. What we get today represents chacruna poorly.
Last edited:
I wholeheartedly agree with @northape. If you're going to a 'held' ceremony you want to make sure the competence of the person holding the space, it's honestly crucial. I don't think they necessarily need years of training deep in isolation in the amazon, however they want to be absolutely very experienced and able to provide the container correctly.

unless you're a connoisseur of these medicines, it will be indistinguishable.Is the difference actually noticeable in practice?
it would be very funny to say that chacruna isn't cosmic. if you want to be humbled, simply drink a higher dose.Does Chaliponga really tend to produce a more visual or “cosmic” experience?
first you'll need a sufficient dose. the setting and the view of the facilitator, particularly how much they interfere with your experience and think they are healing you, will be the foundation of your journey. the admixture is a subtlety you can begin to tune into when you deeply apprentice with the plants.How much of the experience is determined by the plant admixture versus dosage, preparation, setting, and the facilitator (Taita/Shaman)?
chacruna is so lush, she's considered the more gentle one. chali can be more wild (not wild like a rollercoaster per se, but wild like the untamed jungle)If you've worked with both Chacruna and Chaliponga, how would you compare them?
I think you are really misinterpreting the people in this thread. Most of the people here are saying that IF you go to a ceremony, then it's crucial to heavily vet the facilitator because there is a lot of bad apples out there etc, and it's only worthwhile to go when it is with a good one. Many people here have and continue to primarily work with it themselves, they just acknowledge the obvious fact that it can be beneficial, but not crucial, to have a good teacher as well.I strongly disagree that it's important to go to ceremonies.
I agree with @northape that often it is the facilitator or shaman's ego they're trying to press onto others and it's honestly laughable that anyone thinks that they can control or influence the medicine. That's straight from ego. If anyone says that they can influence or guide the medicine themselves, that should be a massive red flag.
It's quite sad to see so many people here advocating for ceremonies. That's a new trend that has emerged since the rise of retreat centers.
I have been a longtime user here for over 20 years and it didn't use to be like that. People were brave and they drank themselves and they actually learned and grew relationships with the plants. They learned how to brew it, they learned different experiences, and they were the true psychonauts.
Now, people are so influenced by dogma and paying money to have someone else give you an experience, and impress their ideals and dogma onto you and the ceromony is very disappointing.
What @universecannon says above is correct. At least from my reading of the topic and my own opinion. No one is here saying it is dangerous or silly or ignorant to drink by one's self, other than logistics of falling over, choking etc if you get a bit out of control. The danger presents itself in groups, that's why I will stand by that it is vital someone chooses the correct facilitator, if they choose to go to facilitated ceremonies. If you wish to drink yourself then there is other prep you should probably do to ensure your safety etc.I strongly disagree that it's important to go to ceremonies.
I agree with @northape that often it is the facilitator or shaman's ego they're trying to press onto others and it's honestly laughable that anyone thinks that they can control or influence the medicine. That's straight from ego. If anyone says that they can influence or guide the medicine themselves, that should be a massive red flag.
I agree. I did mostly solo work (psychedelics on general, not just aya) for about a decade before my partner and some friends joined, and I opened up to the idea of learning from people much more experienced than myself. I still have solo sessions and find them very important in many regards, but they can also be overly serious in a way, and abrasively introspective. I feel more grounded with others. It was difficult getting over the social anxiety but worth it.What @universecannon says above is correct. At least from my reading of the topic and my own opinion. No one is here saying it is dangerous or silly or ignorant to drink by one's self, other than logistics of falling over, choking etc if you get a bit out of control. The danger presents itself in groups, that's why I will stand by that it is vital someone chooses the correct facilitator, if they choose to go to facilitated ceremonies. If you wish to drink yourself then there is other prep you should probably do to ensure your safety etc.
I also stand by the fact that we could learn a lot about psychedelic spaces through interaction and apprenticeship from indigenous people, that's not to say that's not fraught with issues but just respecting that some cultures have been at this much longer than we have and might have a thing or two to share that one might define as wisdom.
Also to clarify, I generally prefer a solo setting for my work at the moment. Though am fond of the group dynamic as well, something special happens when people come together with somewhat aligning intentions.