I've had the most success with mushrooms to be honest, but I'm a bit different then most people on these forums with regards to them since it seems that no matter how low the dose I can breakthrough just about every time.
Not to fly to much into fantasy, but I regard this phenomenon (my exceptionally low tolerance to mushrooms) to be a direct result of being 'chosen' by the teacher. It's like in Avatar; not only do you choose it but it must also choose you.
So I agree with universecannon here that you should cast your net wide and explore many avenues. If the main thrust of Castenada's material was essentially true, then there is a spirit or plant ally that exists behind the actual substance. If this is the case, your temperment and the temperment of teacher may not neccessarily coincide. For instance, in my limited Salvia use not only was I denied access to the breakthrough experience, but I got the sense that whatever Salvia represents did not know what to make of me, whether 'she' could trust me or not. Mushrooms on the other hand seem to fit my loosey-goosey-everything-goes attitude.
The mushroom is my personal chosen teacher, the spirit of which I nicknamed Teo after the aboriginal term for the mushroom deity.