• Members of the previous forum can retrieve their temporary password here, (login and check your PM).

Possibly Becoming Vegan After LSD Trip

Migrated topic.
Pixar said:
jamie said:
"Yes we have been eating meat for a long time, but truth of the matter is we were herbivores way longer before that"

Source?


To say it quickly : "when we weren't homo sapiens". Which doesn't change much in my book.


Woah! thanks for that!
 

This is pretty handy thing to keep in mind when discussing emotionally charged subjects.

If you can't back up your claim, be sure to state that it is simply your opinion, otherwise people are going to accuse you of pushing your opinion down their throats.
 
Lichen said:

This is pretty handy thing to keep in mind when discussing emotionally charged subjects.

If you can't back up your claim, be sure to state that it is simply your opinion, otherwise people are going to accuse you of pushing your opinion down their throats.
Good advice. Good to remember that whoever you disagree with probably believes as strongly about their position as you do about yours. We all see the world through different filters.

And as soon as you attack someone, a common reaction is for them to put up a wall. Walls make it hard to have real discussion. Arguing with reason and understanding has a much better chance at honest open minded communication.
 
OrionFyre said:
Pixar said:
And to Heyt : I don't mind people eating meat and all as long as they don't claim to care about the environment or/and are not aware of the situation.
Speaking of rhetoric...

The meat industry is the largest producer of greenhouse gases, among many other things. Thus, all the little cherries aside, the best thing one can do to help the environment is to not eat meat. If one cares about the environment, one will not eat meat, being aware of the situation.

No logical fallacies here. I'm only saying that I respect people who hold their claims. I'm aware that this is a personal matter : respect. Nevertheless, I know that people not being aware of the situation need evidence to open up and I did not provide that before hand. My presumption on this matter is that we are to beging with in a friendly environment and that everyone here is smart enought to do their own research.

Want to keep on living a lie ? Don't research. Want to be aware ? Do some. I don't give a shit about being civil with people who aren't even open to the idea to beging with, especially when I can tell you are not aware of the situation even though you would like to think you are. I never wanted to enter a discussion on this because I know it most often leads to bullshit, do you own research I don't want this to become a useless interaction. You said something, I countered it with logic (not facts, but I showed the absurdity of what you were saying) but you still don't understand and are reorienting the matter to some idiotic bullshit. Civil is being a hypocrite the way I see it.
 
Pixar said:
The meat industry is the largest producer of greenhouse gases, among many other things.
Yes.

The production of animal-based foods is associated with higher greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions than plant-based foods. The objective of this study was to estimate the difference in dietary GHG emissions between self-selected meat-eaters, fish-eaters, vegetarians and vegans in the UK. Subjects were participants in the EPIC-Oxford cohort study. The diets of 2,041 vegans, 15,751 vegetarians, 8,123 fish-eaters and 29,589 meat-eaters aged 20–79 were assessed using a validated food frequency questionnaire. Comparable GHG emissions parameters were developed for the underlying food codes using a dataset of GHG emissions for 94 food commodities in the UK, with a weighting for the global warming potential of each component gas. The average GHG emissions associated with a standard 2,000 kcal diet were estimated for all subjects. ANOVA was used to estimate average dietary GHG emissions by diet group adjusted for sex and age. The age-and-sex-adjusted mean (95 % confidence interval) GHG emissions in kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalents per day (kgCO2e/day) were 7.19 (7.16, 7.22) for high meat-eaters ( > = 100 g/d), 5.63 (5.61, 5.65) for medium meat-eaters (50-99 g/d), 4.67 (4.65, 4.70) for low meat-eaters ( < 50 g/d), 3.91 (3.88, 3.94) for fish-eaters, 3.81 (3.79, 3.83) for vegetarians and 2.89 (2.83, 2.94) for vegans. In conclusion, dietary GHG emissions in self-selected meat-eaters are approximately twice as high as those in vegans. It is likely that reductions in meat consumption would lead to reductions in dietary GHG emissions.

 
Pixar said:
Want to keep on living a lie ? Don't research. Want to be aware ? Do some. I don't give a shit about being civil with people who aren't even open to the idea to beging with, especially when I can tell you are not aware of the situation even though you would like to think you are. I never wanted to enter a discussion on this because I know it most often leads to bullshit, do you own research I don't want this to become a useless interaction. You said something, I countered it with logic (not facts, but I showed the absurdity of what you were saying) but you still don't understand and are reorienting the matter to some idiotic bullshit. Civil is being a hypocrite the way I see it.
On the other hand, can you convince low conciseness with anger? Or would you just let them be? In the end, it's animals eating animals. It's Homo sapiens eating Bos primigenius taurus. Not very different than a lion eating a gazelle.

Wouldn't it be much smarter to write some vegan cookbooks and get rich, like this guy (Attila Hildmann):

PSC414_JB09609_TH.jpg


I mean you could just laugh your ass off all day, driving expensive cars and smiling at low life meateaters. Your bank, greenhouse and karma account will speak for themselves. No need to be angry because of a single bonehead, when you can change the mind of thousands by example.
 
Ufostrahlen said:
Pixar said:
The meat industry is the largest producer of greenhouse gases, among many other things.
Yes.

The production of animal-based foods is associated with higher greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions than plant-based foods. The objective of this study was to estimate the difference in dietary GHG emissions between self-selected meat-eaters, fish-eaters, vegetarians and vegans in the UK. Subjects were participants in the EPIC-Oxford cohort study. The diets of 2,041 vegans, 15,751 vegetarians, 8,123 fish-eaters and 29,589 meat-eaters aged 20–79 were assessed using a validated food frequency questionnaire. Comparable GHG emissions parameters were developed for the underlying food codes using a dataset of GHG emissions for 94 food commodities in the UK, with a weighting for the global warming potential of each component gas. The average GHG emissions associated with a standard 2,000 kcal diet were estimated for all subjects. ANOVA was used to estimate average dietary GHG emissions by diet group adjusted for sex and age. The age-and-sex-adjusted mean (95 % confidence interval) GHG emissions in kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalents per day (kgCO2e/day) were 7.19 (7.16, 7.22) for high meat-eaters ( > = 100 g/d), 5.63 (5.61, 5.65) for medium meat-eaters (50-99 g/d), 4.67 (4.65, 4.70) for low meat-eaters ( < 50 g/d), 3.91 (3.88, 3.94) for fish-eaters, 3.81 (3.79, 3.83) for vegetarians and 2.89 (2.83, 2.94) for vegans. In conclusion, dietary GHG emissions in self-selected meat-eaters are approximately twice as high as those in vegans. It is likely that reductions in meat consumption would lead to reductions in dietary GHG emissions.



To name a few other important aspects : Raising livestock consumes 1/3 of all the planets fresh water, occupies up to 45% of earth's land, causes 91% of amazon destruction, leading cause of species extinction, leading cause of ocean "dead zones", leading cause of habitat destruction. And we are here talking about our computer's consuming electricty and caring about the environment while putting our fucking face's in meat !?
 
Ufostrahlen said:
Pixar said:
Want to keep on living a lie ? Don't research. Want to be aware ? Do some. I don't give a shit about being civil with people who aren't even open to the idea to beging with, especially when I can tell you are not aware of the situation even though you would like to think you are. I never wanted to enter a discussion on this because I know it most often leads to bullshit, do you own research I don't want this to become a useless interaction. You said something, I countered it with logic (not facts, but I showed the absurdity of what you were saying) but you still don't understand and are reorienting the matter to some idiotic bullshit. Civil is being a hypocrite the way I see it.
On the other hand, can you convince low conciseness with anger? Or would you just let them be? In the end, it's animals eating animals. It's Homo sapiens eating Bos primigenius taurus. Not very different than a lion eating a gazelle.

Wouldn't it be much smarter to write some vegan cookbooks and get rich, like this guy (Attila Hildmann):

PSC414_JB09609_TH.jpg


I mean you could just laugh your ass off all day, driving expensive cars and smiling at low life meateaters. Your bank account and your karma account will speak for themselves. No need to be angry because of a single bonehead, when you can change the mind of thousands by example.

Yes it would, I agree. I don't know how I always end up in these types of discussion even if I don't care about convincing people anymore at all (of that kind). Probably the frustration that commes from seeing all the bullshit arguments beings puked out and them saying we are wrong after and I am frustrated because I care about people, not because I just want to win a debate or some shit like most. I don't want to laugh at people thought, I would like them to understand but I know it is impossible in a lot of cases. In person, whenever I spot someone who I know will be receptive, I give them the arguments/facts/etc.

I know I cannot convince low consciousness with anger, I am not angry even if I am swearing a little just saying. I can be a little to "raw" sometimes, but I think this kind of way to be puts an impression on people that will grow on them with time and encourages more people to do so. I adapt my language with whom I am talking with.
 
Pixar said:
To name a few other important aspects : Raising livestock consumes 1/3 of all the planets fresh water, occupies up to 45% of earth's land, causes 91% of amazon destruction, leading cause of species extinction, leading cause of ocean "dead zones", leading cause of habitat destruction. And we are here talking about our computer's consuming electricty and caring about the environment while putting our fucking face's in meat !?
Easy to solve - only buy locally raised meat or wild caught meat (I get all my meat from a local farm and it only cost a tiny fraction more - no reason the Amazon needs to be hurt to farm meat - that is done for profits). Besides grass land doesnt offer us much food, but is great for cattle. Or raise chickens and pigs which need way less food then cattle (they both love compost too and their poop feeds plants which is also helpful for farming). Not everyone eating meat participates in factory farmed meat. Fish is great too - I like to catch my own.

And are CO2 emissions really that bad for the environment, or is that just a belief created by politicians? I know to most people this idea seems crazy, but temperature stats and honest ice level stats dont lie. Some interesting info out there, and even the man responsible for alerting the world to climate change claims he was wrong!


As for meat having bad consciousness.... What about those poor veggies that you killed and tore up to feed yourself? Plants have consciousness too! Besides, you cant even breathe without killing tons of microbes and every time you poop you kill tons more - truth is we are walking death machines.
 
That material composition that is the body, like a car that runs longer when its fuel is optimized for its engine, is a result of what we have consumed, and a result of Nothing Else.
Vegans live longuer by the way 😉

There is nothing morally wrong with eating meat, please don't get me wrong.
I have to disagree, in the current state of things it is morally wrong to eat meat.

We know the meat industry is the most poluting and destructive of all industries. Eating meat is encouraging this. If we are aware and still chose to eat meat this is morally wrong. If it is not wrong to encorage the most destructive force of the human world knowingly than I don't know what is. What if we made the conditions of animals better like "free range", "organic", etc ? Don't fool yourself, this won't change much at all from their actual living conditions the way things are being done right now.

Now you'll say : where is the data, the facts, the evidence? If you truly cared about this subject more than just seeming to be right or winning an argument you would do your own research, it's out there and it's very easy to access. There is nothing better than finding out for yourself, when someone tells you our prejudices often get in the way.

We have the choice to change our habits and save 90+ lives lived in suffering per year or to keep on living a lifestyle that is currently completely obsolete, that's no longer necessary, just because we don't like change. If it is not morally wrong to live killing and enslaving countless animals when we can live without them then I don't know what is.

When you know, when you are aware, but still chose to eat meat knowing all that is implied by your habits/lifestyle that is morally wrong. At least if morality means causing the less sufforence possible and not killing for no good reasons.
 
travsha said:
Pixar said:
To name a few other important aspects : Raising livestock consumes 1/3 of all the planets fresh water, occupies up to 45% of earth's land, causes 91% of amazon destruction, leading cause of species extinction, leading cause of ocean "dead zones", leading cause of habitat destruction. And we are here talking about our computer's consuming electricty and caring about the environment while putting our fucking face's in meat !?
Easy to solve - only buy locally raised meat or wild caught meat (I get all my meat from a local farm and it only cost a tiny fraction more - no reason the Amazon needs to be hurt to farm meat - that is done for profits). Besides grass land doesnt offer us much food, but is great for cattle. Or raise chickens and pigs which need way less food then cattle (they both love compost too and their poop feeds plants which is also helpful for farming). Not everyone eating meat participates in factory farmed meat. Fish is great too - I like to catch my own.

And are CO2 emissions really that bad for the environment, or is that just a belief created by politicians? I know to most people this idea seems crazy, but temperature stats and honest ice level stats dont lie. Some interesting info out there, and even the man responsible for alerting the world to climate change claims he was wrong!


As for meat having bad consciousness.... What about those poor veggies that you killed and tore up to feed yourself? Plants have consciousness too! Besides, you cant even breathe without killing tons of microbes and every time you poop you kill tons more - truth is we are walking death machines.

More than 10 billions farm animals are killed each year to sustain our demand for meat. How many plants do you think they eat and water they consume ? And how much of the energy contained in those plants will actually be converted to energy our bodies can actually use ?

This is no laughty/silly everyone has there own opinion matter.
 
Pixar said:
OrionFyre said:
Pixar said:
And to Heyt : I don't mind people eating meat and all as long as they don't claim to care about the environment or/and are not aware of the situation.
Speaking of rhetoric...

The meat industry is the largest producer of greenhouse gases, among many other things. Thus, all the little cherries aside, the best thing one can do to help the environment is to not eat meat. If one cares about the environment, one will not eat meat, being aware of the situation.

No logical fallacies here.
That's a blatant lie. You accuse other of using rhetoric, but you yourself are utilizing it just as effectively as everyone else in this thread. You're using emotionally charged language. You make claims that "No true environmentalist" would be a meat eater. That is a logical fallacy and is only being used to hedge your superiority in an argument. Don't worry. You're not alone.

I suggest if you want your arguments to be more effective you stop attacking people's morals or politics by accusing them of "not really caring about the environment.

I don't give a shit about being civil with people who aren't even open to the idea to beging with
And that's why you won't change anyone's mind because you're far too emotionally invested to engage in a discourse without rhetoric.

To be perfectly clear If you're a vegan I admire you. I don't have the time or willingness to put into planning my meals as require to get nutrients. I like the taste of meat also.

What I DO CARE about is when someone comes into an argument accusing someone of using rhetoric as an attack against the man, and then proceed to perpetrate the very same offense in the same breath. THAT is what I was pointing out. DO NOT sit in condemnation of one's use of rhetoric when you're just as guilty.

TO be perfectly clear on this: I am pointedly holding you to task on your use of rhetoric while rebuking someone for the same. Not for your use of rhetoric, but your hypocrisy. It's a nasty dirty trick used in emotionally charged arguments. I am NOT holding you to task for your views or position. If you feel the need to respond to this post then I would ask you to respond to exactly what I am holding you to task for, and to not attempt to move the goal post away from your fallacy as you attempted to do in your first response to me.
 
OrionFyre said:
Pixar said:
OrionFyre said:
Pixar said:
And to Heyt : I don't mind people eating meat and all as long as they don't claim to care about the environment or/and are not aware of the situation.
Speaking of rhetoric...

The meat industry is the largest producer of greenhouse gases, among many other things. Thus, all the little cherries aside, the best thing one can do to help the environment is to not eat meat. If one cares about the environment, one will not eat meat, being aware of the situation.

No logical fallacies here.
That's a blatant lie. You accuse other of using rhetoric, but you yourself are utilizing it just as effectively as everyone else in this thread. You're using emotionally charged language. You make claims that "No true environmentalist" would be a meat eater. That is a logical fallacy and is only being used to hedge your superiority in an argument. Don't worry. You're not alone.

I suggest if you want your arguments to be more effective you stop attacking people's morals or politics by accusing them of "not really caring about the environment.

I don't give a shit about being civil with people who aren't even open to the idea to beging with
And that's why you won't change anyone's mind because you're far too emotionally invested to engage in a discourse without rhetoric.

To be perfectly clear If you're a vegan I admire you. I don't have the time or willingness to put into planning my meals as require to get nutrients. I like the taste of meat also.

What I DO CARE about is when someone comes into an argument accusing someone of using rhetoric as an attack against the man, and then proceed to perpetrate the very same offense in the same breath. THAT is what I was pointing out. DO NOT sit in condemnation of one's use of rhetoric when you're just as guilty.

TO be perfectly clear on this: I am pointedly holding you to task on your use of rhetoric while rebuking someone for the same. Not for your use of rhetoric, but your hypocrisy. It's a nasty dirty trick used in emotionally charged arguments. I am NOT holding you to task for your views or position. If you feel the need to respond to this post then I would ask you to respond to exactly what I am holding you to task for, and to not attempt to move the goal post away from your fallacy as you attempted to do in your first response to me.

No lie here, and the quote you chose has no rhetoric in it, just a logical conclusion to a set of premisse, you don't have to agree with them.

If you find "no true environmentalist" to be emotionaly charged language than that is on your part, because if you accept the premisses I put forth than that is the logical conclusion. I'm critisizing, the critic is not emotionally charged in itself, only the ego's who can't handle them, sorry for saying it how it is once's more.

The best thing you can do for the environment = be a vegan
If one truly care's about it he will become one, once's truly aware of the situation. The last part is the one I think most of the people are missing and it is why you think I am using rhetoric : this is no ornaments it's the real thing. Simple. You don't have to accept it, but if truly caring can be defined as "living up to your words all the way", the opposite being a hypocrite, then it seems to be the most logical conclusion. Show where the rhetoric is now will you ? What you call a "Blatant lie", the foundation for my conclusion, is an actual fact.

To say it briefly : how can a premisse based on facts and another premisse, which you don't have to agree with, be rhetoric when rhetoric is using language in an ornamental way with no true foundation ?

I know what rhetoric is and wouldn't criticise someone using it only to use it the second afterwards. If you were under this impression then sorry to say but this was only an impression.
 
Pixar said:
More than 10 billions farm animals are killed each year to sustain our demand for meat. How many plants do you think they eat and water they consume ? And how much of the energy contained in those plants will actually be converted to energy our bodies can actually use ?

This is no laughty/silly everyone has there own opinion matter.
Never said anything was silly. My view is that life needs to consume other life to survive. Even plants consume other life. Just how things work.
 
:( I thought the Nexus was above this. I feel like I'm being attacked when I came in this thread in a polite, non-confrontational way.

Heyt said:
Personally psychedelics have increased my love of meat, but also decreased my consumption. On some high dose mushroom trips, I reconnected with my hunter/warrior side and found a greater appreciation for the animals we eat. Now I only eat free range eggs (which are a million times more delicious and far healthier) and kill most of the meat I eat myself. While I used to feel guilty about killing a deer, for example, I now see it as the circle of life and hope that when I die I can be food for something as well (we all are, when we decay).

Plus, I believe that more traditional and green methods of raising livestock can give the animals far better living conditions than in the wild. I buy a lot of pork from my aunt who specializes in humane farming. Commercial farming though is absolutely evil.

So maybe I'm the outlier here, but I still feel like I completely understand your perspective OP. I think the same feelings and empathies drive our very different lifestyles. I now look at hunting rabbits and ducks and deer as the circle of life, and have deep respect and spiritual awareness for the creatures I kill, though I prefer to fish when possible as fish lack C type trauma fibers (there has been no peer-reviewed evidence of pain in fish that's withstood scrutiny so far, so I feel no guilt in fishing for food). I now see hunting and fishing as an entheogenic experience in its own right.

Good luck with the vegan lifestyle OP, I hope it works for you! Psychedelics can definitely be a great catalyst for transformative growth. :thumb_up:
 
"The meat industry is the largest producer of greenhouse gases, among many other things. Thus, all the little cherries aside, the best thing one can do to help the environment is to not eat meat. If one cares about the environment, one will not eat meat, being aware of the situation. "

What is "the meat industry"? I don't really even want to have this discussion because it is so obviously biased the way you have chosen to word it that many people see right through it.

You seem to not make any distinction between factory farming of cows, and meat in general...which seems common among people who have emotional bonds to the idea that veganism is a high moral position vs omnivoires. I work in horticulture, and have worked in agriculture..and this arguement is laughable at best. All the land that is cleared for conventional mono-culture farming(organic or not) for crops that you are buying, is hardly environmentally friendly.

A person eating foraged wild greens, berries and hunted animals like birds and fish, or supporting local perma-culture farms is far far ahead of you in terms of what is environmentally ethical.

Some people for instance eat fish 2-3 times a month, that they catch themselves and do not consume any farmed animal products. Those people are doing more towards a sustainable lifeway than a random vegan buying imported plants from exotic locations and factory farms. Do you know how many animals are either forced out of they're homes or simply killed in order for land to be cleared so your plants can be grown? You don't have veganism or vegetarianism outside of agriculture. There are NO examples of this among homo sapien sapien. Argue it all you want..all the archeological evidence is stacked against the idea that we were ever anything but omnivoires.

My teacher and the woman who taught me perma-culture knows more about the sustainabilty of eco-systems than probly anyone else posting in this thread, and she is definitely not a vegan.

When I studied environmental ethics in college, my teacher would have thrown your arguement right out and told you to come back with something less biased and more representative of the situation as a whole.

You are picking and choosing individual points to support your belief system but seem unwilling to acknowledge the wider picture that conflicts with that belief.

There are so many things that are just silly about the claim that meat eating is the cause of the degradation of the environment. Capitalism is an anti-environmental stance. The meat industry is not much different from the oil industry, or the corn industry, or the soy industry, or the sugar industry...

Pick your battles wisely, or waste your time with fallacies.
 
Back
Top Bottom