I personally think Hawking is a great example of an exception to that humble part. That guy drives me nuts. Brilliant yes... He said, I guess, that science had proven conclusively that there is no God. I think that was really presumptuous.
Citta said:jamie:
So what if they say it to be di-atomic instead of mono-atomic? Or both? It doesn't save their asses from the incredible claims they are making and the fact that they wish to sell products on the basis of this! Just like Masuru Emoto they don't have any scientific references to show to, just these shabby internet sites where they talk about their bullshit. These people are either quacks and scammers, or they are simply deluded.
Now, just because there is so much we don't know about the universe this doesn't constitute an argument at all in your favor. You bring this up alot. It is a classical mistake to claim that since we don't know everything, we therefore can't be sure of anything at all; and not be able to say whether or not something is likely. This is obviously wrong and is a thought mistake - a non sequitur - because it is akin to say that since we haven't mapped all huts and shelters in the Amazon, we can't say for sure that there isn't a skyscraper in the middle of the Sahara Desert. A person that claims there is a skyscraper in the middle of Sahara; or that the earth is flat; or that clouds aren't caused by water vapour but that god created them ex-nihilo; or that the sun goes down in a pile of mud in the west; is simply wrong and there is no reason to be apologetic about that.
Furthermore no real scientist claims to know it all, in fact scientists are very good at admitting there is something they do not know when they actually don't. You see, it is a great liability in science to claim to know something you don't, or can't possibly know, so that is not done. Most scientists are very honest and humble people, and they know it pretty damn well when there is something they do not know, and they admit it right away. To take an example; often at science conferences where someone presents some results or talks about something, a scientist within one specific field will immediately let his audience know when he is talking about something outside his area of expertise. He will typically say "I don't know very much about this, but I think...", "This is not my field, but...", "You should ask someone else, but..." and so on. You don't see this coming from pseudoscientists, deluded people, quacks or scammers - often you don't see this attitude coming from many religious, spiritual or mystical people either.
The Dunning-Kruger effect is quite relevant here as well.
jamie said:lol thanks for adressing my actaul question..
jamie said:Ever heard of a magnetic vortex water trap? I would really like to know what people are seperating out in this "trap" water..because just saying all the ormus people are crackpots is kind of ignorant. I bet you have never even investigated this yourself.
jamie said:BTW I never said ormes was real or that science cannot know anything. I never said that ANYWHERE so please do not put words into my mouth. Can you please go back in this thread, or anyh thread and find a quote of me saying that "science cannot know anything about the universe"?.. Really, since that is your response to me I would love for you to go do that.
jamie said:I mentioned that these people are comming up with something that they call ormes(and some do not even call it that), so if you want to say it is all bunk can you please explain to me what it is they have? It is bad science to pass something off completely without actaully looking into it yourself first.
This is absolutely true, but we must be careful about walking down the path that is implied by such statements.Citta said:For example, contrary to what is being said in this video, we don't know whether or not consciousness creates matter, but we do know that there is nothing in science to suggest it does.
gibran2 said:This is absolutely true, but we must be careful about walking down the path that is implied by such statements.Citta said:For example, contrary to what is being said in this video, we don't know whether or not consciousness creates matter, but we do know that there is nothing in science to suggest it does.
“Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.”
We have no evidence of those things for which we have no evidence. This is a tautological fact, but it doesn’t really strengthen one belief over another.
Not too long ago, scientists could honestly state “we don’t know whether or not the Earth revolves around the sun, but we do know that there is nothing in science to suggest it does”. You can substitute any unknown into that sentence and get many statements that today sound very foolish.
gibran2 said:This is absolutely true, but we must be careful about walking down the path that is implied by such statements.Citta said:For example, contrary to what is being said in this video, we don't know whether or not consciousness creates matter, but we do know that there is nothing in science to suggest it does.
“Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.”
We have no evidence of those things for which we have no evidence. This is a tautological fact, but it doesn’t really strengthen one belief over another.
Not too long ago, scientists could honestly state “we don’t know whether or not the Earth revolves around the sun, but we do know that there is nothing in science to suggest it does”. You can substitute any unknown into that sentence and get many statements that today sound very foolish.
tele said:Absolutely true, it's unfortunate how for many(or even most people) “Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence” isn't obvious.
endlessness said:Except when the god damn gnomes play tricks on me, and I look in my pockets, cant find the keys, then I look everywhere else, and after hours I look again and, guess what, the keys are in my pocket! :lol:

wrists said:it is my understanding that discrediting an individual, scientific or not, is rather naive.
wrists said:alot like our human experience, until we know for a fact what is really going on around us, all avenues should be looked at.
wrists said:I personally like the idea of all these metaphysical aspects existing and we should find a way to study this type of phenomena, scientifically instead of discrediting it as mumbo jumbo.
wrists said:after all who are we to say that one opinion is more valid than anothers unless there is irrefutable proof of course
wrists said:our opinions are like the other thing we all have, we need to move past that to have a completely open mind to properly observe
jamie said:I can build one for 15 bucks. I dont care what someone sells it for or what they claim the stuff is. That is not my point, nor was it EVER my point. You avoided my point again. I have seen what comes out of these water traps..it is clearly seperating the water into 2 parts..so what is the section of water that is magnetically repelled? Until you adress that whatever these people are comming up, they are comming up with *something* saying you have debunked it just makes no sense.