• Members of the previous forum can retrieve their temporary password here, (login and check your PM).

sodium bicarbonate into sodium carbonate question

Migrated topic.

edun

Rising Star
Joined
Oct 28, 2012
Messages
15
Merits
42
Hi everyone!!

Just a quick question... I tried to convert sodium bicarbonate into sodium carbonate following the advice in the wiki (here: Conversion of Sodium Bicarbonate into Sodium Carbonate - DMT-Nexus Wiki). I used Arm & Hammer pure sodium bicarbonate and placed it in a pot and over my stove for over an hour at full flame. I´m PRETTY sure that it went well over 150-180°C (if not more, I can't be sure). It's supposed to break down at around 80-100°C.

The thing is that I've read everywhere that when the change is done the substance physically changes, it turns from a powder to a salt like grainy appearance. My didn't. It remains perfectly fine powder.

Is there a way to chemically prove that it turned into sodium carbonate?

Oh, BTW, during the heating it started smelling AWFUL! I take that's a good start.

I just might try harder to find commercial sodium carbonate. I honestly did and couldn't find it.

Thanks in advance!!
 
Did you weigh before and after?

If you compare it with fresh sodium bicarb, it should def have a different consistency, maybe you just dont notice it now because you dont have some bicarb to compare?

I dont recall it smelling aweful and I see no reason why it should, since its just releasing CO2 and H2O. Was it stainless steel pot? Hopefully not some teflon pot
 
I honestly didn't weight it. I just eyeballed the amount in the package before and after the heating and it doesn't look like there's a 20% difference (actually I see no difference at all, lol).

Actually you're right, I don't have any bicarb to compare. But it doesn't get any more powdery than what I've got :P

And yes, I used a stainless steel pot.

You know what, I'll just look for the right stuff and stop baking bicarb. But thanks a lot Endlessness!! :D
 
Back
Top Bottom