On a typical Nexian thread that forked and sped down tangential alleyways, we began discussing ideal government structures, entheogenic community organization and such heady things.
I put forth my long thought on model for a Meritocratic, non-representational system. But it was obvious that we had derailed that thread so far from the OP that it warranted its own thread.
So, I invite all and sundry to come here and propose, debate and discuss your favorite fantasy systems of governance. It is rather apropos at this time, considering that many of us Americans here have no government right now... due entirely to our truly unbelievably asinine representatives reaching a new low, even for them. And this is a group that has had public support ratings of 10% or under for many, many years now.
I will quickly outline what I mean by a meritocracy.
It was obvious to me decades ago that Democracy is insufficient. It means well, in the ideal... but I don't think that everyone should have equal say on every subject. (see the old thread for discussion on the elitism subject)
Basically put, as worthy as a mentally handicapped child may be, his opinion on fiscal policy is not equal to that of a Nobel Prize winning economist... no liberal guilt and hand-wringing can alter this. We should embrace this fact and not pretend that all opinions are equal.
I think an ideal utopian meritocracy (with or without entheogens) should be structured in such a way that everyone gets a vote proportional to their knowledge on the topic being voted upon. We can argue about how merit should be accrued or recognized, but this seems like the most intelligent way to go forward.
No representative government. The public votes on everything they feel like voting about, have interest in... and their knowledge and eminence on the subject is factored in. Personally, I wouldn't mind if the highest experts got 100x the vote of normal folks. In fact... I think you should have to take a short test on the subject in order to have any vote at all. If you can't pass the most cursory of tests on what the bill proposes... then your vote is worthless anyway.
(note: I borrowed some from my post in the previous thread to save time)
Alright my esteemed colleagues... have at it. Let's see if we can't devise something workable. I have already got my concept fairly well hammered out, but it would be rather presumptuous to think that it is ready for prime time. After all, there have been no truly new political systems put forward in over 100 years.
I put forth my long thought on model for a Meritocratic, non-representational system. But it was obvious that we had derailed that thread so far from the OP that it warranted its own thread.
So, I invite all and sundry to come here and propose, debate and discuss your favorite fantasy systems of governance. It is rather apropos at this time, considering that many of us Americans here have no government right now... due entirely to our truly unbelievably asinine representatives reaching a new low, even for them. And this is a group that has had public support ratings of 10% or under for many, many years now.
I will quickly outline what I mean by a meritocracy.
It was obvious to me decades ago that Democracy is insufficient. It means well, in the ideal... but I don't think that everyone should have equal say on every subject. (see the old thread for discussion on the elitism subject)
Basically put, as worthy as a mentally handicapped child may be, his opinion on fiscal policy is not equal to that of a Nobel Prize winning economist... no liberal guilt and hand-wringing can alter this. We should embrace this fact and not pretend that all opinions are equal.
I think an ideal utopian meritocracy (with or without entheogens) should be structured in such a way that everyone gets a vote proportional to their knowledge on the topic being voted upon. We can argue about how merit should be accrued or recognized, but this seems like the most intelligent way to go forward.
No representative government. The public votes on everything they feel like voting about, have interest in... and their knowledge and eminence on the subject is factored in. Personally, I wouldn't mind if the highest experts got 100x the vote of normal folks. In fact... I think you should have to take a short test on the subject in order to have any vote at all. If you can't pass the most cursory of tests on what the bill proposes... then your vote is worthless anyway.
(note: I borrowed some from my post in the previous thread to save time)
Alright my esteemed colleagues... have at it. Let's see if we can't devise something workable. I have already got my concept fairly well hammered out, but it would be rather presumptuous to think that it is ready for prime time. After all, there have been no truly new political systems put forward in over 100 years.
... humans are improvisors at all levels, especially in their political institutions. Meanwhile collective institutions are the main realm for the realisation of the virtues, that is, for the realisation of the human good. If the good can't be realised in our collective ways of being, it becomes largely impotent, a subjective longing, a wistful dream. In which case we as individual humans are frustrated, and not as fully realised as we could be, and, correlatively, we are menaced by institutions bereft of moral integrity.