I enjoyed both of your perspectives. I agree in some respects. He is a dick when challenged and that is hard to read/hear. He tends to assume the idea is settled when personally I feel things are still inconclusive or at best could stand to be fleshed out more. And he does seem to claim the methods of the trivium when it is clear he has yet to get a full grasp of it.
That being said, I think his homework doing ness is applaudable. Also, I am very much impressed with his associates in the Tragedy and Hope community and find little flaws in their works and would assume (although not necessarily rightly so (innocent by association fallacy? haha)) that he would not be so well accepted into their circle if they shared our reservations.
In direct response to the wasson, huxley, mckenna connections to cia and mind control, I think again he has left a few things out that I've tried to piece together from my own studies. What I've come to believe is that the connections are enough for him because he understands how certain entities have worked in the past and forgets that not everyone else has the same things in mind, thus leaving out some key connections.
"Ordo ab chao" is a familiar motto to most. Another thing to remember, which may not be so familiar, is the worship of the owl, with it's significance being sight within the darkness. There are more "loose ends" than direct connections, but when one remembers that the introduction of Prussian schooling greatly reduced the mental capacity of the "average individual" it starts to make sense that releasing psychedelics onto a generally illogical society would create a chaos that could be steered to a desirable result. One also has to remember that there is a difference between assets and useful idiots. I would call huxley an asset (though not in the cia sense but more as a person knowing what he's doing), mckenna a useful idiot, and wasson somewhere in between.
To take a step back, think of the history of these compounds/plant allies. Before recent times, their use was restricted either to a "priestly" class or to administration by a priest or shaman that guided the experience. It was in many ways a religious experience but more importantly it was guided by a logic that was defined in terms of the language associated with the particular substance. These types of experiences (elusian mysteries, ancient peyote rituals, egyptian pyramidal rites, etc) were arguably way more "successful/effective" due not only to the fact that there was a structure, but there was a selective nature to choosing participants or at the least a serious preparation given from an individual who did little else. In this context it's only mind control if the priest desires to exert some influence over the participants (which undoubtedly happened in many cases), but otherwise the participants and priests had a good degree of control over their own minds.
Today, we are not taught to control our own minds. In fact it can be argued that we are "taught" (through "outcome based" education) to shift from an internal to external locus of control. In this context, without some guiding force (outside of the substance itself, for while it may seem like a guide, it is merely a vehicle) chaos typically ensues. Many people have brightening experiences, being lifted from the gross mundane reality that our society beats into one's head but that is generally super-ceded by an external influence: zen buddhism, tarot, "gnostic" christianity, crystal work, reiki, positivism (not to be confused with optimism), tech worship, focus on "dna activation", obsession with alien contact, and other things, delusional or otherwise, which have some established center of dogma. It must be quickly added that one can participate in any of the preceding without joining some sort of following or giving in to dogmatics, but (and I speak from experience here) it is difficult to avoid when first becoming familiar with these substances unless one has already developed a firm basis in reason and understanding.
That is to say, and here I will speak of my own acts, that when you're fresh out of high school, thinking you know what's what and you have a completely game changing experience with some form of psychedelic, it is very easy to look to these "teachers" such as mckenna, tolle, watts, leary, rand, blavatsky et al, and be mesmerized. To hear their words and accept them before you think about them. Yes, it's an ignorant thing to do. No, I do not think everyone immediately accepts everything they hear. But I know that it is easy to believe. And that we are taught to believe. And that when you introduce psychedelics into a culture without a systematic structure of understanding (not ritual, that is unnecessary) and guidance, cognitive dissonance is basically a given. It takes a good amount of time to develop understanding. And it takes a strong foundation of understanding to begin to provide guidance worth accepting. And I don't think it's being shared with us.
To get back on topic, my understanding is that there is not one force or entity controlling the world, but rather there are many forces attempting to, and many of them have similar goals or methods. The way that huxley wasson and mckenna fit together with this is that Huxley comes from a family that represented the interests of the highest class, the class that historically (and potentially presently) had access to the guidance and understanding required to bring order from the chaos of the psychedelic experience. His agendas were largely focused on eugenics and social control. Wasson is a front man for elite bankers (a group largely interested in social control as it is a means to maintain their position). He runs PR for them, and even worked in the OSS during the war if I remember correctly, then he popularizes a substance which makes pr (read propaganda) way easier. Mckenna furthers that by being a front man for the mushroom. He advocates social control, links human development to psychedelics vis a vis the stoned ape theory (Wanna evolve? eat shrooms!), and even directly advocates population reduction, bringing the triangle full circle. Yes there are many more angles, many more agendas, many more things that psychedelics can do. But that is the nature of all tools, Thor used a hammer to smash, Jesus used it to build.
The focus I think should be on what you plan to do with psychedelics. I have changed since my post high school days by moving from entertainment to self development. I realize most posters here have a focus on the latter, but even we who know what should be done aren't always equipped to do so.
To sum up all of the above in one sentence: The agenda pushed by those that Jan has demonized is one of converting a tool to a weapon where we as individuals must learn to turn our swords to plowshares.