primordium
Rising Star
Graham Hancock publicly asks the ever-confident atheist Richard Dawkins to ingest a shamanically-used psychedelic.
[YOUTUBE]
[YOUTUBE]
What for?primordium said:Graham Hancock publicly asks the ever-confident atheist Richard Dawkins to ingest a shamanically-used psychedelic.
According to a 1996 article in The Los Angeles Times, when Mr. Burroughs once described a psychedelic trip as an earth-shaking metaphysical experience, Dr. Schultes's response was, "That's funny, Bill, all I saw was colors."
:surprisedThen again if you take ayahuasca and don't have a spiritual experience then you are unworthy and just not good enough. Only the true of heart and the smart have spiritual experiences on psychedelics...
I am kidding of course
roll: ). Someone might say "I took LSD and it had a big impact on my life, but it wasn't a spiritual experience". In that case, I wonder if that person and I simply have different definitions of "spirituality". My opinion is that everyone is affected deeply by psychedelics, though some people don't like to admit it or just are not aware of it.I will admit I am too lazy to come up with my own definitions of words and just use the prepacked ones in the dictionary. So for me the definition of spiritual isn't up in the air at all, it is definite and easy to look up.I somewhat disagree because the definition of spiritual is up in the air (Rolling eyes ). Someone might say "I took LSD and it had a big impact on my life, but it wasn't a spiritual experience". In that case, I wonder if that person and I simply have different definitions of "spirituality". My opinion is that everyone is affected deeply by psychedelics, though some people don't like to admit it or just are not aware of it.
Amygdala said:I have no personal opinion on the man, as I have never met him...
My (limited) understanding of his work is that he has made a quest to debunk the 'supernatural'.
In a way, I don't have any problem with that either. The problem becomes when it is assumed that we have such a thorough understanding of the 'natural', that we automatically exclude phenomena that we cannot as of yet explain.
If you look through the history of human knowledge, the supernatural becomes the natural as our understanding increases. If we dogmatically shut the doors on things that we don't understand, we are doing science and humanity a disservice. Do you believe that in the year 2100 we will still consensus believe the same things we do today? How about 2500?
To me at least, the natural is the mystical. Even if you try or are able to explain away the material universe, don't you ever take a step back and say, holy hell look at this crazy thing. Its f'n amazing. How lucky I am the be a part. That is a spiritual experience.
First of all, every experience is a drug experience, and since experiences are the sole source of beliefs, it is reasonable to conclude that psychedelics can lead to changes in beliefs and behavior.AlbertKLloyd said:...
Atheists can enjoy psychedelics without having their beliefs change... it is silly to think that a drug experience is tantamount to a spiritual experience. In my opinion if you depend upon a psychoactive for spirituality you are spiritually bankrupt. If you are already spiritual the psychoactive can help, but why base a testimony upon the experience of a mind tripping? That is like learning to drive by sitting on the toilet, in my opinion that is.
...
hixidom said:Also, Richard Dawkins is an anthropologist, so I'd be surprised if he didn't already know about Ayahuasca. It's not like Graham is introducing him to some unheard of thing.
InMotion said:Something tells me a guy like dawkins has done psychedelics
InMotion said:Something tells me a guy like dawkins has done psychedelics. He seemed to know a fair bit about shamanism off-hand. Probably didn't want to have it effect his career though.
jamie said:People claiming to be atheist is to me like people claiming to be catholic..doesnt mean much other than that you have decided to believe in one of the two polarities.
Knowing a lot about the other big university city and the history of both the town and gown side of things I would say that if it's anything like that and shares anything like its history then the opposite is probably true.cyb said:InMotion said:Something tells me a guy like dawkins has done psychedelics
I highly doubt it InMo...he's an Oxford boy and fairly well brainwashed by that particular society, one sniff by the faculty and you were out...a bit of weed floating around campus..no doubt..but psys..I dunno bout dat.
I couldn't imagine them even reaching that town in the 60's let alone inside the Uni... (I could be wrong though)