That's very bad advice. Do not heat naphtha directly. Always use a pre-prepared hot water bath to heat flammable volatile solvents!Running Bear said:2. Use something like a crock pot to heat the naphtha.
Running Bear said:Doesn't remove yellowing? That's not true at all.
1. If you had done so much research, then when are you still SWIM'ming? It's a deprecated style here.Feoom said:I know there are a lot of threads about re-x, and most of them i have seen and researched. So i guess my question isn't being answered. Freeze precipitation doesn't give you the crystals SWIM is looking for, it doesn't remove yellowing and it takes a few days that is because crystals form the best while slow decreasing the temperature. Thats why evaporating is "best" for growing crystals.
How do you know so certainly that it will actually work out the way you say it will? Did you do any experiments before posting your questions? Watching youtube videos does not qualify as an actual experiment.Feoom said:But with the tek i am researching it takes only a few hours to get purified crystals if the solvents allow it.
But does "SWIM" know how it works for someone who is skilled in the art?Feoom said:SWIM is not interested in your tek, since SWIM know how that works. SWIM is just looking for more "better" options that suits him.
If your question is suited to the "Advanced Chemistry" section, it might be replaced there by a forum moderator. But I doubt that this question is.Feoom said:Maybe my question is for the "Advanced Chemistry" section. But i am not allowed to post their yet.
pitubo said:
It did raise some doubts with me, enough to warrant mentioning it. Plus, most of the references that you gave were youtube videos and none referenced the multitude of topics on this forum. To be honest, I am still not convinced that your ideas are thoroughly researched, though neither can I state with full conviction that they are not.Feoom said:Is that really a relevant question? Are you suggesting by this i have not done my research? Seems to me like a short turn to judge.pitubo said:1. If you had done so much research, then when are you still SWIM'ming? It's a deprecated style here.
Don't feel too harshly judged by my criticisms. Take it as an encouragement to do more work and further refine your ideas and proposals. Maybe it will some day lead to an interesting new development.Feoom said:No, i havent experimented yet. Thats why i am asking my question for researching and help from people who have tried it. So i can't be for sure. Thats why i am saying. 'if' this works it would be great for the whole re-x proces. At least that is what i think.How do you know so certainly that it will actually work out the way you say it will? Did you do any experiments before posting your questions? Watching youtube videos does not qualify as an actual experiment.
I don't need to be a moderator to point out your disregarding of the rules of the forum. If the whole responsibility to flag breaches of the rules lies with the moderators, then the forum would quickly lose both quality and moderators.Running Bear said:You'll be a moderator in no time..
pitubo said:I don't need to be a moderator to point out your disregarding of the rules of the forum. If the whole responsibility to flag breaches of the rules lies with the moderators, then the forum would quickly lose both quality and moderators.Running Bear said:You'll be a moderator in no time..
And it is not petty confrontational behavior to speak out when unsafe practices are being promoted. Your response on the other hand...
Diazin said:Sorry, I mis-read your op, thought you wanted to an alternative for freeze-precip.
In this case, as pitubo said, ethanol will leave the spice gooey and still yellish when evaporated.
Okay, let's go back to my actual posting that caused you react like you did:Running Bear said:It's not what you said, it's the way you said it.pitubo said:I don't need to be a moderator to point out your disregarding of the rules of the forum. If the whole responsibility to flag breaches of the rules lies with the moderators, then the forum would quickly lose both quality and moderators.Running Bear said:You'll be a moderator in no time..
And it is not petty confrontational behavior to speak out when unsafe practices are being promoted. Your response on the other hand...
AFAICS its all constructive criticism and none is worded particularly awkwardly.pitubo said:That's very bad advice. Do not heat naphtha directly. Always use a pre-prepared hot water bath to heat flammable volatile solvents!Running Bear said:2. Use something like a crock pot to heat the naphtha.
Also, a little more formatting might make your contributions easier to read and digest.