• Members of the previous forum can retrieve their temporary password here, (login and check your PM).

are beta carbolines bad for you

  • Thread starter Thread starter 00
  • Start date Start date

00

Rising Star
Joined
Feb 15, 2024
Messages
25
Merits
42
I read on the Internets that beta carbolines are turned into 2N methyl beta carbolinium cations, which kill dopamine neurons. They say it is sort of like the neurotoxin MPTP, which causes permanent symptons of Parkinson's disease. Should I be worried!?
 
Long term ayahuasca use has not shown any such problems to exist. If any damage was done, it seems that such users would have suffered from it, and they appear to be fine.

That's not to say that it doesn't cause some damage at some level, but whatever damage it may cause apparently goes undetected in long term ayahuasca users.

I recommend not using anything of this nature on a daily bases.

Passionflower is a common herb and has been studied quite extensively and has not shown any long term adverse effects on health. Like rue and caapi, it too contains betacarbolines.
 
I *believe* (someone chime in to correct me if I'm wrong, I read this in a book I loaned out and never got back :evil: ) a lot of the beta carbolines in Caapi are very similar to beta carbolines naturally produced inside the body, especially pinoline. Pinoline is a very powerful antioxidant, moreso than melatonin.

Not sure about dopamine, but Caapi also repairs the seratonin system in the brain. It can aid in the treatment of depression.

Also, there are lots of studies done on long-term members (10+ years) of the UDV (an Ayahuasca church). They compared long-term members to non-Ayahuasca-drinking subjects, and the members of the UDV handled stress better, were very integrated into their social structures, scored the same or better on cognitive tests, and gave up alcoholism. (I have a hard copy of the book Ayahuasca: Sacred Vine of Spirits that details the studies.)

So there is a lot of data that supports the long-term use of Caapi--and, the betacarbolines present in the vine, at least--are actually very beneficial. :)

Another book I would recommend is Left in the Dark, by Tony Wright. LOADS of amazing information (this was the book that turned me on to Ayahuasca).
 
Have there been any studies on Parkinson's disease in ayawaska drinkers.
 
There are studies linking pesticides like paraquat to Parkinson's disease. Paraquat is N methyl pyridinium cations like MPP+, which is the metabolite of MPTP that kills neurons.
 
Hey 00 I know the studies you are talking about. I have been looking into this but its difficult to find anything conclusive. It appears this group in japan (and i think a couple others) has spent quite some years studying possible environmental toxins that could lead to parkinson's disease. There are beta carbolines in wine and things like this etc so thats one group that was looked at.

So far the only real major one thats ever been identified is MPTP yes which is metabolized into MPP+. This was found on accident when some opiate users injected some badly synthesized material and well got parkinsons from it. Also like you said some pesticides may be linked. Now the drug is used to purposely induce parkinsons in animal models etc.

However the beta carbolines in b caapi don't seem to be harmful from prolonged use judging from observations of regular uses.

Many of these studies you are talking about are directly injecting these compounds into rat brain and although the control causes no significant damage the compounds do. But they may be metabolized before getting into the brain differently (when administered orally etc) and not cause any damage. There could also be differences in the test models rat versus human.

I think the lesson is that not all beta carbolines are safe. But there are so many so of course some are going to be dangerous especially when they are so similar to endogenous compounds. In truth though no one is entirely sure. But I think moderate use of ayahuasca and syrian rue preparations is fine. Some people use it very often and they don't get acute parkinson's like conditions even from chronic use. But again no ones specifically ever looked for this kind of damage in ayahuasca users. Although parkinson's itself would be very obvious.

I wonder if the groups doing this research even thought of ayahuasca. Probabaly not from reading their papers. They don't even mention that theres this huge population using beta carbolines via ayahuasca in any of their studies. Personally I think they were onto a hypothesis that never wound up going anywhere.

But again I am sure there must be some neurotoxic beta carbolines out there just not the ones in b caapi at least not at the levels that they are found. I think thats a safe conclusion.
 
Back
Top Bottom