You talk about there being contradictions in Buddhism and one big reason is that Buddhists can't even agree which is the authentic tradition. You have Zen, Theraveda, Mahayana, Nichiren, Tendai, Vajrayana...You say not to mix traditions, so if that's the case, only one school of Buddhism can be right, but more likely is that historically traditions have been mixed, changed and adapted for centuries. If you think Buddhism is the genuine spiritual path, you'd better hope you've picked the correct, authentic one.
From a non-dual perspective, it seems outright contradictory to say that "someone is enlightened" because using the formula of saying "anyone is_anything" is an inherently dual statement. I think it's naive interpretation to assume that enlightenment or buddhahood is this inherently permanent state. I've never seen direct evidence for this permanence, and as such it stands as a large assumption. I'm quoting myself from recently:
It's ironic that you talk of Buddhism arising from direct experience because the same holds true for psychedelics. Despite the fact that Buddhism may have been derived from direct experience and that said experience is still potentially attainable today, it still must be taken completely on faith that you will arrive at your end goal until you actually do. It is also textbook projection to assume as well that what psychedelics cannot do for you, cannot be done for everybody (which goes hand in hand with the yogi who took LSD and called it "super samsara" - maybe if he had taken a significantly larger dose and merged with the void, that he may have been of quite the different opinion). If someone through the use of psychedelics has perceived themselves as being one with the All, God, Buddha, etc...who is anyone who wasn't explicitly present to inauthenticate it?
Imagine you're on your Buddhist path which is like a metaphor of going through live by climbing a mountain with enlightenment being the peak. As you go through your life, your Buddhist mentors reassure you that the only way to the peak is through a long, arduous life of drudging up that mountain one foot at a time. Time goes by, and you grow old. You feel the end can't be far. Approaching from the other side of the mountain is a metaphorical psychonaut in a helicopter. He falls out of the helicopter hitting the peak, and going on rolling down the mountain from there. Now he can say he saw the top, but could the aspiring Buddhist? Food for thought.
From a non-dual perspective, it seems outright contradictory to say that "someone is enlightened" because using the formula of saying "anyone is_anything" is an inherently dual statement. I think it's naive interpretation to assume that enlightenment or buddhahood is this inherently permanent state. I've never seen direct evidence for this permanence, and as such it stands as a large assumption. I'm quoting myself from recently:
Global said:I think part of the problem is the language we use when we say "someone is an enlightened being" because there is sort of this implication that the person is always enlightened. It's kinda like if you were to call a person nervous...sure they are - right now - but in a different setting or even just the passing of time, that person's state of being can fluctuate and change entirely. I think there can be fleeting moments of enlightenment in the same way that there are fleeting moments of butterflies in the stomach or feeling one's heart racing.
Perhaps we can think of ourselves like a piece of string. This string has been wound around a pole for most of its existence. Now someone comes along who takes the string off the pole and can stretch it between his hands so that the string is perfectly straight. The string momentarily enjoys this perfected state of being. When the person decides to let go of the string, the string almost instantly begins coiling back up again, even in the absence of the pole. The string may be capable of remembering what it's like to be "straightened" but he cannot will it just because it has been done before, and telling the other coiled strings about it doesn't directly make their coiled lives any easier.
It's ironic that you talk of Buddhism arising from direct experience because the same holds true for psychedelics. Despite the fact that Buddhism may have been derived from direct experience and that said experience is still potentially attainable today, it still must be taken completely on faith that you will arrive at your end goal until you actually do. It is also textbook projection to assume as well that what psychedelics cannot do for you, cannot be done for everybody (which goes hand in hand with the yogi who took LSD and called it "super samsara" - maybe if he had taken a significantly larger dose and merged with the void, that he may have been of quite the different opinion). If someone through the use of psychedelics has perceived themselves as being one with the All, God, Buddha, etc...who is anyone who wasn't explicitly present to inauthenticate it?
Imagine you're on your Buddhist path which is like a metaphor of going through live by climbing a mountain with enlightenment being the peak. As you go through your life, your Buddhist mentors reassure you that the only way to the peak is through a long, arduous life of drudging up that mountain one foot at a time. Time goes by, and you grow old. You feel the end can't be far. Approaching from the other side of the mountain is a metaphorical psychonaut in a helicopter. He falls out of the helicopter hitting the peak, and going on rolling down the mountain from there. Now he can say he saw the top, but could the aspiring Buddhist? Food for thought.