• Members of the previous forum can retrieve their temporary password here, (login and check your PM).

timothy learys ideas and internet freedom

Migrated topic.

timothylearysdead

Rising Star
Joined
Jul 5, 2012
Messages
53
Merits
42
I was watching this:
It occurred to me that the concept-itself was destructive to the very nature of internet communities. Obviously this is no ordinary internet community; and so I wonder what people's opinions of his ideas are?

Is there such a thing as 'authority figures' in psychedelic communities? If so, what should be their roles: To promote freedom of speech and thought in a non-critical environment; or to promote intellectual control to prevent cultural conformity, and arbitrary opinion-bearing?

Is the very concept of 'total' freedom anti-intellectual? What is the point in discussing anything at all if there is no progress to be made? Is that THE final solution; or an impenetrable stagnation at the beginning of any sensible coherent-thought. Are we making progress towards freedom, if the freedom gained gives conformity towards the power structures of existing social-hierarchies; and spreading of religious-belief as opium for the masses?

Hopefully these are some interesting points, and hopefully the responses will be more interesting still.
 
Any responsible website has to abide by rules in order to flourish, or be at risk of being removed i guess.

Fact is this, our freedom is dictated by the laws of the country we reside in, and your government dictates the freedoms you are allowed.
 
Words and sentences convey ideas.
Ideas convey thoughts.

Should thoughts be controlled?
What is the purpose of controlling thoughts?

Progress. But progress towards what?

Is freedom a barrier to progress? What progress in thinking can ever be made by restricting thought of others?

I hope that all are open minded enough to consider these points. I recall a quote from Tim Leary "I never imagined that I could be wrong, until I learned to imagine that I could be wrong."
 
Every human relationship has rules, whether they are implicit or explicit. Following or ignoring rules will have different consequences, depending on the context and specific relationship.

To think that there is 'freedom of speech' here (or anywhere else) is an illusion, there is only relative freedom within the guidelines we have created. The attitude page, which exposes our rules and guidelines, is one of the main reason why this forum is so different from others, take your time reading it if you havent yet: Attitude Page - DMT-Nexus Wiki

The final word is always from The Traveler, which is the administrator of the Nexus. He does all the programing, spent countless (unpaid) hours in creating and maintaining this place and spends from his own money the server and other costs. Nevertheless, there is a diverse group of moderators which help him out and are here to aid with the structure and direction of the forum, to give guidance and establishing a good atmosphere, as well as enforce the rules if necessary. We dont want to and for long periods dont have to use our moderator rights to 'enforce' the rules, but you can be sure if some troll or spammer or person with bad intentions and attitude comes to the forum and refuses to acknowledge our working after being warned, this person will be banned. We always chose the mediation and dialogue before, and try to work out the problems by calmly pointing out our ideas, but sometimes that isnt possible, as those who have been here for long have seen.

We are of course open to change, to suggestions, and we have changed different policies due to the feedback from users, who help us out a lot. If someone is not happy with the way things are run, they can always give constructive criticism and suggest things, and this can be dialogued between members and try to reach a consensus. There is a whole subforum where suggestions can be made. In the end we're all humans and can make mistakes, so the feedback from the members is essential. This is how we work.

Regarding the people here being "free and open minds who use DMT", well, not sure. There are certainly many very special characters here, some incredible people and a very special atmosphere. But we are also all humans with our own flaws and traits, we're not enlightened people.

Lastly, about what are our interests, I guess we have the diversity of the individual interests, which synergize/interact with each other plus the established Nexus structure to form the community interests, and this is embedded within a cultural framework where society's interests are. Sometimes some interests may be conflicting, like say, general society may at least officially be against drug use, so in this sense, we are at odds. But at the same time we are looking for learning and helping people develop themselves, so at least in theory society also wants that. Also, 'society' is way too general because this would have to include different cultures which have different interests, since this is an international community. As for, specifically, what the Nexus wants, it is to "learn, share and expand", within the framework of our stated attitude. Learning about ourselves, psychedelics and the world, sharing results of experimentation and knowledge acquired here and elsewhere, and expanding the community's knowledge and ourselves as human beings.
 
endlessness said:
To think that there is 'freedom of speech' here (or anywhere else) is an illusion
I disagree. The IDEA itself: that 'freedom of speech' IS an illusion; also makes it an illusion.

The idea of 'trolling', again, can be misunderstood. This thread could be seen in that light; but that would be closed off from seeing the beneficial effects of constructive criticism. The immediate response of viewing criticism as 'bad' is another society-based reaction, that need not be adopted where people have a loose attachment to words.

All opinion expressed is simply an expression of thought. There is no negative effect to be found in criticizing a persons thoughts. The result can only be a more reasonable, more rational mind. And a stronger, independent personality. Criticizing an opinion is not criticizing a person.

A person's worth is independent of the nature of their opinions. The nature of their opinions is only worth something within society. We exist at the edges of society, individually, and as a community.

By not promoting criticism, in the name of preserving a 'friendly attitude'; attachments to the thoughts are made - rather than the thought being ABOUT reality, the thought is seen as-being a part OF reality. This is obviously detrimental to peoples mental health; and negatively impacts understanding of psychedelic experiences.

I would argue that avoiding such criticism in the name of politeness is ultimately detrimental to the community. It is everyone's intention to be free from relentless abuse; and it is everyone's nature to be nice towards others. But as a community where people use DMT, this attitude promotes relentless abuse the other way - to people who have opinions imposed onto them; representing collective delusions. This is the message that most peoples 'signatures' convey, and it is neither a benign nor healthy message to have spread. (not yours, by the way!).

Simply thoughts.
 
Seems you didnt really read what I wrote? We never said criticism is not desired, we directly promote constructive criticism, there is a whole subforum dedicated to suggestions and constructive criticism.

If you think the Nexus attitude is about politeness, I think you didn't 'get it'. Did you read it thoroughly? How long have you been reading the Nexus, and how long have you been reading other forums around?

You are speaking in way too generic terms anyways, if you'd like to point a specific example and give an alternative view on how we could work, feel free. When I mean trolling, I dont mean someone being unpolite, I mean someone consciously disrupting the Nexus for the sake of it. Those who are here for long know what I mean.

There are many other forums out there that are more loose in terms of regulations (though they will still have their own regulations), people are free to join them any time, or make their own forum. Here, our attitude page is the main guide on how the posting should be, and we know from experience that this is the best way. If you'd like to suggest a change to it, you can post and other members and mods and trav can voice what we think about it.

Here's another link for you The illusion of free speech - Announcements and Suggestions - Welcome to the DMT-Nexus
 
endlessness said:
Seems you didnt really read what I wrote? We never said criticism is not desired, we directly promote constructive criticism, there is a whole subforum dedicated to suggestions and constructive criticism.

If you think the Nexus attitude is about politeness, I think you didn't 'get it'. Did you read it thoroughly? How long have you been reading the Nexus, and how long have you been reading other forums around?

You are speaking in way too generic terms anyways, if you'd like to point a specific example and give an alternative view on how we could work, feel free. When I mean trolling, I dont mean someone being unpolite, I mean someone consciously disrupting the Nexus for the sake of it. Those who are here for long know what I mean.

There are many other forums out there that are more loose in terms of regulations (though they will still have their own regulations), people are free to join them any time, or make their own forum. Here, our attitude page is the main guide on how the posting should be, and we know from experience that this is the best way. If you'd like to suggest a change to it, you can post and other members and mods and trav can voice what we think about it.

Here's another link for you The illusion of free speech - Announcements and Suggestions - Welcome to the DMT-Nexus
I appreciate what you are saying. I did read it thoroughly. The idea of 'deliberate disruption just for the sake of it' may also be a simple misunderstanding of intent: If someone contributes something - consistently and coherently - it is a contribution to the collective thinking, which may simply be incomprehensible to the reader.

I appreciate that serious discussion can be detrimentally-affected in this way, of course, but it works both ways: When serious discussion is sought, and asked for, it is equally a conscious and deliberate disruption to fail to understand the points being made. (This is not referring to your response, by the way. :) )
There are numerous examples of this on here, and on any forum - it simply displays a lack of understanding. When some people see pointlessness in ANY discussion, one wonders why they discuss anything at all. There are indeed other forums, but few related to DMT.

I am a member of a Russian DMT forum - we primarily discuss philosophy; this is done using constantly changing (and interchanging) usernames. There is then no-knowledge of who is making the comment; or whether it is the same person's input, or a different person's input. This stops any prejudice from being formed based upon personality-type, and the strength of any model proposed can be assessed upon it's usefulness. This reductive-approach seeks to remove all prejudices of belief; and allows for real, practical application. The demonstrable effect is to allow for the development of means to understand the nature of subconscious thought; how it is expressed in written and spoken language; and how it may be interpreted and used fully. By removing all associations towards language-based concepts, study and progress can be made from outside of these constraints.

Essentially: when we speak, we speak our minds; when we read, we interpret someone else's mind; when we understand, we read someone else's mind.
The implications of this are deeper than may be imagined. I state it plainly because it appears to be a minute play on words to wider-society, but those interested in psychedlic drugs and DMT can appreciate the concept - the only barrier is the model of philosophy that the person accepts. To communicate this concept is difficult, and requires a different paradigm to fully understand; which the DMT experience provides either in-part, or in-full. Several attemps to communicate this information, however, have been met with total dismissal, and mostly an inability to understand the point. The prejudices of belief make it impossible for most of society to imagine. But the restraint of self-deluding philosophies also make it impossible to imagine, and that is seen frequently.

I state these points neither as recommendations, nor proposals: they are simply ideas - which CAN be understood, and which CAN be advanced. Stagnation of thought and progress within understanding the DMT experience is NOT inevitable. All experience is due to the subjectivity of individual perception. This applies equally to science - and it does NOT prevent progress in itself. The concept of what 'rules' to impose communally; and for what purpose; and for what outcome - is therefore an important one.

I fully agree with the 'attitude', and I fully agree with your points too.

The position of the 'leaders' is what drives any public community. Interaction with other communities who share a similar interest, similar experiences, and a lesser/greater amount of knowledge is possible via the internet on a global scale. However, when attempts have been made to share this information with largely-American audiences; the ideas are rejected, removed, or not taken seriously at all. When intelligent discussion is rejected on the basis of misunderstandings on the part of the reader; based upon their prejudices; and their (learned) belief in the equivalency of their opinion; the community is collectively-unreceptive to new ideas, and collectively numbed to attempts to educate. This very-word seems to elicit a defensive response in some people. Education is done with the intention of HELPING people towards MORE freedom.

What I personally believe to be the cause of unreceptiveness is an idealized view of Eastern religion; which is prevalent in many attitudes expressed here. There is no reason why a community should not be isolationist if it chooses - but if a community doesn't realize that it is - or cannot REALIZE that it is - it needs to be told; directly and indirectly. The act of 'telling' is then misconstrued as trolling etc., and accounts get banned. Then the 'rules' prevent the contribution of good information, and encourage the facile, unchallenging principles instead.

Like a pupil and a teacher: the teacher gives, and the pupil receives. What the pupil can give to the teacher is a fresh perspective, but the pupil can provide little reason. When the teacher talks to other teachers, they can add reason, and create USEFUL perspectives. The teacher can then give back MORE to the pupil. With a class-full of pupils, and no other teachers, the teacher becomes an unquestioned king. In one school, one attitude develops. In academic discussions, the discussions are between equals - but the non-equals have been excluded. In private discussions, hierarchies are seen publicly; in open discussions - the leaders enforce the majority view, and then the majority enforce stagnancy of thought, conformity of thinking, and a blanket of selfish-indifference.

Word games are not always circular. Words are not all pulling the same strings; words do not carry equal weight; progress is made by restricting freedom. Unrestricted freedom is not progress. Progress is engineered by the permitting - moveable - restrictions in thought.
Equality of opinion is a restriction to the intelligent, and a freedom for the unintelligent. Any restriction that encourages the majority belief is encouraging the majority in a collective delusion. Any collective delusion allies people towards society. The removal of delusions can be catalyzed by DMT. But it is only lasting with the aid of intellectual and ethical control within the supporting community.
Ethics of wider-society does not, and cannot, have these values. To choose NOT to believe in beliefs, is NOT choosing a 'belief system'.

That is my main point. I can't really say much more than that. It seems to be a subject of little interest; but so it goes.
 
^^ Im finding your perspective pretty interesting, timothlearysdead.And welcome to the Nexus.

First of all, having read this thread several times, I now think I understand what you're stating, and the questions you ask don't strike me as trolling.Its just a little tricky to decipher on first assessment your positions which does seem to vacillate a little.But I guess thats where your interest/experience of the 'philosophical' approach comes in. This is something that Ive no proficiency in but I find myself agreeing with you that all opinions are not equal. This position does go against the modern and so-called progressive 'beyond questioning' notion of equality (or equivalence) to all comers and speakers. But, IMO, this is a rather vapid position, once a little mental effort is expended in actually thinking about what this equality means.I like this debate which considers this in a way I found useful:



I dunno if I fully agree with your statement suggesting that any restriction that encourages the majority belief necessarily means encouraging the majority in a collective delusion, because sometimes the majority opinion can be the most correct.But not always.

I do agree that the concept of 'total' freedom is an abstraction which doesnt lend much support to either sides of the argument as its just, IMO, an Utopian musing, and cannot really add in a tangible fashion to progess.

I also wonder if the conclusions you reach are necessarily as applicable to an Internet Forum as they may be to real life.Peoples abilities to express themselves in the written word may not always accurately convey what they wish to transmit, and the absence of the cues one can get in a face to face exchange are just not available through this mode of communication.

Nevertheless, interesting stuff.
 
corpus callosum said:
I also wonder if the conclusions you reach are necessarily as applicable to an Internet Forum as they may be to real life.Peoples abilities to express themselves in the written word may not always accurately convey what they wish to transmit, and the absence of the cues one can get in a face to face exchange are just not available through this mode of communication.
I shall refer you back to paragraph 3 and 4; especially, and literally, the last sentence. On another point that you made: "When everyone has a voice, then no one is heard". The tendency to view all communication as an exercise in idle discussion is a nearly impenetrable cultural viewpoint. It is one that I do not share; neither personally, nor culturally.
Regarding the preconception that there can be 'no-progress'; it is neither the position of science, nor is it the position of philosophy. When dealing with a drug that affects the brain as remarkably as DMT does: the philosophy of logic and language; models of perception and cognition; and awake/dream states of reality are central to understanding, or using, the experience.
The importance of this is unfortunately demoted in many discussions. An outlook which views the experience as ultimately-unfathomable, and accepts it as unusable (beyond any personal gain) is not born out in the knowledge of history, or of experience. This leads more experienced members to do themselves and their own knowledge, a great-disservice; by feeling-obliged to state that they know no-more than a bewildered child.
It is simply a matter of viewing the experience from a different philosophical outlook. Such online cooperation already HAS led to useful philosophical models being identified, and developed. Practical advancements have been shown in the interpretation of subconscious thought through written language; in the study of numerology; in the refinement of neurological models towards the DMT experience. These have all been achieved. There is a wealth of information presented within the scientific, psychological, and philosophical literature which may be developed for practical application through interactive cooperation. This is ongoing already. I shall attach some books, and I shall leave it there for the moment.
 

Attachments

timothylearysdead said:
corpus callosum said:
I also wonder if the conclusions you reach are necessarily as applicable to an Internet Forum as they may be to real life.Peoples abilities to express themselves in the written word may not always accurately convey what they wish to transmit, and the absence of the cues one can get in a face to face exchange are just not available through this mode of communication.
I shall refer you back to paragraph 3 and 4; especially, and literally, the last sentence. On another point that you made: "When everyone has a voice, then no one is heard". The tendency to view all communication as an exercise in idle discussion is a nearly impenetrable cultural viewpoint. It is one that I do not share; neither personally, nor culturally.
I shall attach some books, and I shall leave it there for the moment.


Could I trouble you to point out paragraphs 3 and 4 specifically to me, so we both know to what you refer? Thanks.

Im not certain I made the point that 'When everyone has a voice, then no-one is heard".I also don't subscribe to the view that all communication is an exercise in idle discussion.

Thanks for posting the links-I will certainly check them out.
 
Timlearyisdead,

Whilst i agree that people should think for themselves, i think that they will figure this out someday in their lives. What you can do though, is sow some seeds to the sleeping and leave them figure out the rest. A sort of "fill in the gaps" if you like.

This forum like most forums has it's rules to follow, so you can't do whatever you want, if it's not allowed. I guess the only other option for your kinda levels of freedom would be to start up your own forum or look for another one. Arguing about this isn't gonna help.
 
corpus callosum said:
Could I trouble you to point out paragraphs 3 and 4 specifically to me, so we both know to what you refer?
I am a member of a Russian DMT forum - we primarily discuss philosophy; this is done using constantly changing (and interchanging) usernames. There is then no-knowledge of who is making the comment; or whether it is the same person's input, or a different person's input. This stops any prejudice from being formed based upon personality-type, and the strength of any model proposed can be assessed upon it's usefulness. This reductive-approach seeks to remove all prejudices of belief; and allows for real, practical application. The demonstrable effect is to allow for the development of means to understand the nature of subconscious thought; how it is expressed in written and spoken language; and how it may be interpreted and used fully. By removing all associations towards language-based concepts, study and progress can be made from outside of these constraints.

Essentially: when we speak, we speak our minds; when we read, we interpret someone else's mind; when we understand, we read someone else's mind.
christian said:
Arguing about this isn't gonna help.
This is a discussion; an exchange of ideas. How is it useful to tell anyone - who is contributing something clearly and rationally - to 'stop arguing and go to another forum?' It is not your decision to make. You haven't read what I have written; you haven't understood what I have written; you have made the same point as previously.

It always helps to discuss everything. It may help you more than it helps me; if you can imagine such a thing? It certainly helps no one to prevent sensible discussion. If you don't understand it: don't read it; don't comment upon it. It's not your place to dictate what is acceptable, or useful for other people. Unless you speak with the consent of others, and on behalf of others; in which case it is - and I apologize.
 
timothylearysdead said:
I am a member of a Russian DMT forum - we primarily discuss philosophy; this is done using constantly changing (and interchanging) usernames. There is then no-knowledge of who is making the comment; or whether it is the same person's input, or a different person's input. This stops any prejudice from being formed based upon personality-type, and the strength of any model proposed can be assessed upon it's usefulness. This reductive-approach seeks to remove all prejudices of belief; and allows for real, practical application. The demonstrable effect is to allow for the development of means to understand the nature of subconscious thought; how it is expressed in written and spoken language; and how it may be interpreted and used fully. By removing all associations towards language-based concepts, study and progress can be made from outside of these constraints.

Essentially: when we speak, we speak our minds; when we read, we interpret someone else's mind; when we understand, we read someone else's mind.


The DMT Nexus, unlike the Russian forum you refer too, primarily discusses DMT and entheogens and has some philosophy too but not as its prime focus.I would be interested to take a look at the Russian site and I'd be grateful if you could provide a link to it.I hope its in English, or allows translation of its content into English.

Im struggling to see how the approach that site takes allows the removal of all associations towards language-based concepts when the communication/exchange of ideas utilises language...but perhaps I need to view the site, and read the links you've provided, to understand this.
 
timothylearysdead said:
Is the very concept of 'total' freedom anti-intellectual?

You'll have to ask The Traveller this question. I'm sure you know that total freedom is not allowed in Society. To think otherwise would be incorrect. The Government have their strategies, and we know what we are up against. People have been fighting for personal freedom since the dawn of time. Just look at the "war on drugs".

This is what you are up against. We all know that forums have rules, and they have rules to maintain the ongoing use and continuation of the smooth running of the forum. Certainly, the forum owners don't want to put their sites at risk of attracting the wrong kind of attention from newbies that have their own agenda aside from forum rules?

The forum basically has to be Government friendly, because after all they are in charge of our dictating our freedom.8)
 
Back
Top Bottom