Purges said:
We evolved as hunter gatherers - 'gathering' was only a part of our diet.quote]
Hmmm, do you have a source for that? While it is true that we have been eating meat for a long long time, there is no evidence really to prove that we have evolved such complex nervous systems with meat as part of our diet. The most convinving theory is that we evolved such complex brains back in the tropical forests of africa as mainly fruitarians, with some leafs and nuts and seeds etc.
There are a number of reasons that this theory outweighs the probability of the savannah theory-that we evolved on the savannah on a diet consisting of lots of meat. We did become human so there was some change and some researchers think that some of our ancestors did leave the forests and then return to the forests and that the ones who left and stayed on the savannah eventually died out and these are some of the primate species we find and assume are earlier forms of man-but it might not be that simple.
Anyway my point is that saying we evolved eating meat is not entirely true. We have eaten meat for a long time, but we deveoloped the nervous system we have a LONG time ago and the evidence just does not support the idea that it happened as meat eaters.
This is sort of way way too complex to get into here though and I am no evolutionary biologist. Get the book left in the dark if you want something that will cover many of the bases of evolutionary theory and diet.
I'm sure I could find quite a few sources to back this up, just as I am sure you could find your own sources to back up your hypothesis. I'm sure the truth exists some where in between.
Now, let's have a look at our closest evolutionary ancestors. Chimpanzees. they certainly won't turn their noses up at a bit of meat, they will even cannibalise. I have video evidence of this:
Now this serves a few purposes in my view -
It broadens their territory, they have probably for ever frightened the competition from their turf, which is a positive for the chimps in the long term.
It provides protein and iron and other things that are in short supply in most of the fruit and vegetation that they eat.
And also this sort of pack mentality is important for the survival of this particular species. it hones their strategical combat skills for times when they themselves are under threat from other primates, big cats etc
Now meat may not be their primary food source granted, but then consider when people were moving further north to inhabit colder climates. They would have had to endure times of great hardship when the land was covered in snow and ice and there was very little vegetation to be seen, let alone eaten. they would have had to adapt their diets to suit their environment. So there would have been dried fruits, grains which store for a long time and so on, but that wouldn't be able to entirely sustain them remember that this is pre-agriculture, which was certainly a game changer.
So yes, for these reasons I believe eating meat became a fundamental part of our evolution very early on.