InneffableThings said:
I understand the dislike of the word morality. It is most often used to describe a rigid belief system of right and wrong. Nonetheless, I do think morality is the closest word many people have to describe their heart, so only treating the word as a bad thing is a great misunderstanding.
Because of this I will use the word morality to mean having a connection to one's heart, letting the heart speak instead of thoughts and habits.
Of course if someone is following a belief system rigidly it will likely separate them from their heart. So we can then say morality is immoral, which is very fun and true.
But let me clarify again, I do believe a person cannot stay connected with their heart or reach anything greater without overcoming their moral belief structures.
Oh, I neither like nor dislike the word 'morality', it is just a word. But as a word used to express a state of human awareness, it is entirely subjective. Your morality is not the same as mine, we might find common ground and agreement on some things, but this does not hold true for all things. For instance our discussion here about eating meat. Some find it moral, others immoral and both are right and both are wrong. What may be good to you, may be evil to another and vice versa, or any shade inbetween. I think the only term that comes close to expressing heart centered awareness would be compassionate wisdom, which in its pure form is blind. Everyone and everything in existence is learning lessons and expanding themselves and the universe as a whole, each has its own path to bring infinite awareness to All That Is. The very nature of the word morality is based upon duality and right/wrong. I understand how you are using it, but by doing so, even in the way you have, you trap your awareness in duality.
Following
any belief system, no matter how rigid or supple, separates you from your heart. The key is to do what feels good, what brings you joy by following your heart, be a Pathfinder...don't believe anything, but rather know that your heart centered awareness will never lead you astray. Find that path so others may follow (if they choose), and now you have become a Wayshower.
This is the old argument. It is difficult to find a belief system to hold on to at these levels which does not immediately cause one to lose truth. Yet the strength of our survival minds require an "inoculation belief" to assist and guide us in recognizing our clinging. Personally, I think the reason the heart is so compassionate towards individuals, and all of the great teachers have exhibited this in their action even though not necessarily in their words, is because there is no human rational description of the universe that can be true. So we can say what we have said, but none of it truly reflects the truth of the entirety of the universe, which is much greater than piddly human ideas of what an individual or non-duality means. And when we meet an individual, if we are tuned into the universe, and into our heart, we do not want them to suffer as an individual. And we are unable to give a reason why.
Just because it is an old argument, does not mean it is invalid. The concept of all as the One (which by the way fits in perfectly with Big Bang Theory and quantum mechanics) seems quite rational to me. Do I believe it? No. Does it make rational sense to me? Yes. I agree that to try to understand the entirety of the universe, or try to make it fit nicely into a little box from our human perspective is absurd and fruitless.
I can give a reason why we do not want others to suffer from this perspective. Because that other is me, and I am the other, so their suffering is my suffering. I feel their suffering whether I am conscious of it or not and I do not want to suffer, except when I do want to suffer.

Their suffering teaches them something about themselves and about me.
I think you are using the word animate to mean what I mean with individual. I'm not very hung up on words and am fine with either.
I would direct this to my previous Charles Manson argument. I think this can be boiled down to one question: "Does the life of a blob of animated consciousness matter?"
So I say the life of animated consciousness is a beautiful thing. Perhaps rocks and space and trees are alive as part of the unified consciousness, or just the cycle of life and death, but I do not think they are as alive as animated consciousness as cows, which I do not think are as alive as animated consciousness as humans.
I suppose I am, except I am using it to include all plants, microbes, bacteria, anything that traditional science would consider "life". I am not taking away from the uniqueness of the human condition, nor that of life that has more developed consciousness, but rather elevating all other life (and even that which most don't currently consider to be life) to an equal state of value.
And it is far from meaningless, but exactly the opposite. Everything matters, because without it all we would not exist. The dirt under your feet are just as important for without the minerals contained within, your body could not regenerate itself. The air you breate fuels the cells and enables them to reproduce using the nutrients we take in from the atomosphere. You cannot separate yourself from the universe as a whole, 'living' and non 'living' matter. We and all life are in a constant state of flux, ever changing, ever adapting one portion of the universe to another. Life just is, and it is everything.
This life as a human isn't your first time around the block. Your individuated consciousness has been an atom, a rock, a cloud, a snowflake, a drop of water, plants, animals, etc... You have complexified over an unimaginable amount of time to your present level of aware consciousness, and it goes beyond from here. Our level of consciousness is akin to being a rock to what is out there...
I have spent a lot of time in meditation with animals, plants, humans, and rocks over this question. Not meditating on the ideas, as that is very different, but with them. Over and over, as far as I can tell, my heart tells me animated consciousness has value unto itself, even though I do not understand it. And also, that there is "more and less" animation, though I also do not understand this and I find few people who are comfortable with this notion. I have spent a good amount of time studying complex systems and chaos, I think this may be why I am comfortable that there are tangible means of measuring such things.
Sitting and meditating in nature is precious. Try an experiment...and perhaps this is what you are already doing. Try communicating with some of those things. Become the rock, become the plant, feel their awareness. Open your heart and mind, and connect with them, ask them questions and listen for an answer...you might be surprised at the response you get. Everything has an awareness, and they like to talk to us, its just that we have disconnected ourselves so much from nature that very few know how to listen. This holds true the other way as well. There is consciousness that is beyond our own that is trying to communicate with us, and we are just beginning to hear what they have to share with us. I agree that there is "more and less" animation (id use the word awareness), but that does not mean that one has greater value than another. Measuring is separating, and puts you in duality consciousness rather than unity consciousness.
Thank you with all my heart for this conversation. You have helped me immensely to expand my own understanding.
Love and Gratitude