Eliyahu said:
AlbertKLloyd wrote:
There is also the idea of acting directly and acting indirectly that can factor into the meanings. Shamans tend to have no power, they ask spirits to help them do things, so do sorcerers, but sorcerers also act directly and have power.
Sounds like some majorly preconcieved notions you have there based on some fairly weak generalizations IMO
It is quite demonstrable with historical evidence, that is not actually in debate.
I comepletely agree with Jamie. Quite frankly I believe many non-spiritualist people are a way too nit picky and hyper sensitive about the terminology surrounding psychedlics and terms like shaman, entheogen, medicine-man etc as if it's some how offensive to their supposed lack of beliefs...
I am rather spiritual and still take issue with those terms, it has nothing to do with being PC.
Psychedelics have been used for spiritual purposes since the dawn of mankind hence the various luingistic phrasing that has developed around it's use.
Define spiritual purposes here, because they have been used for MANY things. One might say they have been used for ANTI-spiritual purposes just as often.
Also, according to Albert, only people from south america can be real shaman? Why is that? Is there some kind of cringo DNA that inhibits the ability to be a proper shaman?
I never wrote nor implied that.
Actually if you read what I wrote (you clearly didn't) I mentioned that the South American traditions are not particularly Shamanic, hence the term is misleading. However if we do apply the term Shaman you can also read that I wrote the following:
And frankly the sorcery practices that are being called Shamanic are things that many people can do without any guides or apprenticeship.
Yeah, rather than say that only people from SA can do it, I said that pretty much ANYONE can. If you know the right techniques or the right spirits to invoke results are easy.
Albert, who are you to say who can and who cannot be shamen?
Nobody, given that I did not write or say that.
May I suggest reading what I write before attempting to address it?
Jamie and I agree about a lot of the content of this topic, believe it or not. An example of this is the use of the terms; witchcraft and brujo. He is totally accurate in my opinion about that, and I would add that for me the label shaman is as fitting to the South American traditions as the term Witchcraft is. We may disagree about that, but still we are mostly in agreement. The problem with the term witchcraft is far beyond being PC, that really has nothing at all to do with the topic.
In reality there are terms for these people in their own languages. This is what they truely are.
Agreed, this was the point of the Andean anthropologist, he said that sorcerer was closer as a translation than Shaman was. It is still a word alien to those cultures, but I feel that it is more accurate than any other label I can think of, though it lacks perfect aptitude.
The Serpent and The Rainbow should be required reading for this thread!
I made this into it's own topic. Enjoy.
Cool, my only concern is this:
A person dying in the care of one of these so called "shamans" is not unheard of in the classic literature, actually it is not uncommon.
For me this is a major part of both this discussion and the other one. That people are taken aback by the idea of the death, but they should not be, because Shaman has a connotation that is far too positive in contrast with the more neutral tradition peoples view becomes tainted as it were by the labels. The idea that someone died in the care of a traditional style south American ayahuascero should not be so shocking or surprising. It does stand in contrast to the way we view these practices today, but it is kind of ordinary in a historical and traditional sense. I agree that the hiding of the body and the lying are things that people should be shocked at, but the death is not, in my opinion. Nor should people attribute the death to the ayahyuasca without autopsy suggesting it, again in my opinion, there is lots of evidence that Aya is generally safe and that Andean shamanism (if we call it that) is potentially dangerous, for many reasons.
I also agree with previous comments in the other thread about the exploitation of these traditions in a capitalistic manner, I too feel that this is a
potential source of problems.
you think within the shamanic culture of siberia there is not this same dicotemy between "good" and "evil"?
Yes (to a degree but not absolutely) in terms of practice of "attacks", however in terms of social roles of those whom we label I think that a more significant dichotomy emerges between the Andean practices and Siberian/Asian practices. I would say that the Andean practices are closer to Voodoo in many ways than they are to Siberian shamanism for example. The serpent and the rainbow comes to mind again, and those who have studied will note the rainbow serpent is found in the Andean traditions.
We have this term today used more widely and in a general sense due to people like Eliade, and Michael Harner..both of whome seemed to idealize the whole thing and perpetuate an air of misunderstanding IMO that has plagued the anthropology world ever since.
AMEN!