I mentioned earlier the irritating term or tag "Angry Young Man," with which awkward types are put in their place as callow young rebels going through a "phase." In 'Look Back in Anger', the mediocre play by John Osborne that gave currency to the usage, the protagonist Jimmy Porter is going through one of his self-regarding soliloquies when he exclaims, rather tellingly for once, that there are "no more good, brave causes left." This utterance struck home in the consciousness of the mid-1950s, at a time when existential anomie was trading at an inflated price.
Within a few years, I need not add, millions of young people had forsaken the Absurd in order to engage with such good, if not invariably brave, causes as the Civil Rights movement, the struggle against thermonuclear statism, and the ending of an unjust war in Indochina. I was myself "of" this period, and have witnessed some truly marvelous moments at firsthand. (I shan't tell you my stories unless you specifically request them; I know that nothing is more tedious than the front-line recollections of a Sixties radical.)
Nobody in the supposedly affluent and disillusioned fifties had seen any of this coming; I am quite certain that there will be future opportunities for people of high ideals, or of any ideals at all. However, in the fairly long interval between 1968 and 1989--in other words in that period where many of the revolutionaries against consumer capitalism metamorphosed into "civil society" human rights activists--there were considerable interludes of quietism and stasis. And it was in order to survive those years of stalemate and realpolitik that a number of important dissidents evolved a strategy for survival. In a phrase, they decided to live "as if."
I'm never certain which author can claim the credit for this mild-sounding but actually deeply subversive and ironic decision. Vaclav Havel, then working as a marginal playwright and poet in a society and state that truly merited the title of Absurd, realized that "resistance" in its original insurgent and militant sense was impossible in the Central Europe of the day. He therefore proposed living "as if" he were a citizen of a free society, "as if" lying and cowardice were not mandatory patriotic duties, "as if" his government had actually signed (which it had) the various treaties and agreements that enshrine universal human rights. He called this tactic "The Power of the Powerless" because even when disagreement can be almost forbidden, a state that insists on actually compelling assent can be relatively easily made to look this stupid. You can't achieve 100 percent control over hyumans, and if you could, you could not go on doing so. It is--fortunately--too much responsibility for any human to assume, not that this keeps the control freaks from continuing to try.
At around the same time and alarmed in a different way by many of the same things (the morbid relationship of the Cold War to the nuclear arms race), Professor E.P. Thompson, whom I recommended to you earlier, proposed that we live "as if" a free and independent Europe already existed. Some people are still offended if yen mentions these two men in the same breath--and Thompson would never have claimed that they both ran the same risks--but actually the two movements for human rights and disarmament were latently symbiotic at the beginning and had become quite closely related by the end. And we know with certainty, from the memoirs of some of the "statesmen" of the period, that it was the stubborn, nonviolent, cultural and political rebellions of those years that impelled them to recast their assumptions. The process often involved an inversion in the usual relationship between the ironic and the literal. The "People Power" movement of 1989, when whole populations brought down their absurd rulers by an exercise of arm-folding and sarcasm, had its origins partly in the Philippines in 1985, when the dictator Marcos called an opportunist "snap election" and the voters decided to take him seriously. They acted "as if" the vote were free and fair, and they made it so. (The forgotten fact that the Soviet ambassador to Manila took the side of Marcos was also a portent of a kind.)
Again, I've slipped into recounting these legendary moments as if they vindicated dissenters, as they most certainly do, and as if they were self-evident "good, brave causes," which they most certainly were. But it's important to remember the many dreary years when the prospect of victory appeared quite unattainable. On every day of those years, the "as if" pose had to be kept up, until its cumulative effect could be felt. Many of the greatest "as if" practitioners--including Thompson himself, and men like Frantisek Kriegel in then Czechoslovakia--did not live long enough to see the grand production for which they had kept up the optimistic but phlegmatic rehearsals.
One could add further examples. In the late Victorian period, Oscar Wilde--master of the pose but not amere poseur--decide to live and act "as if" moral hypocrisy were not regnant. In the Deep South in the early 1960's, Rosa Parks (after some arduous dress rehearsals of her own) decided to act "as if" a hardworking black woman could sit down on a bus at the end of the day's labor. In Moscow in the 1970s, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn resolved to write "as if" an individual scholar could investigate the history of his own country, and publish his findings. They all, by behaving literally, acted ironically. In each case, as we know now, the authorities were forced first to act crassly and then to look crass, and eventually to fall victim to stern verdicts from posterity. However, this was by no means the guaranteed outcome and there must have been days when the "as if" style was exceedingly hard to keep up.
All I can recommend therefore (apart from the study of these and other good examples) is that you try to cultivate some of this attitude. In an average day, you may be confronted with some species of bullying or bigotry, or some ill-phrased appeal to the general will, or some petty abuse of authority. If you have a political loyalty, you may be offered a shady reason for agreeing to a lie or a half-truth that serves some short-term purpose. Everybody devises tactics for getting through such moments; try behaving "as if" they need not be tolerated and are not inevitable.