• Members of the previous forum can retrieve their temporary password here, (login and check your PM).

The Case Against DMT Elves - James Kent

Migrated topic.
cellux said:
Tek said:
We should stop trying to argue this point. Subjective experience is exactly that; subjective. Nothing can be proven in this regard, but if you REALLY get it, you know you don't NEED to prove it. The experience is enough to convince certain people, others not so much.

Citta and benzyme (and burnt) really gave me a headache :) when they claimed that they in fact HAD had these deep spiritual experiences, they just drew entirely different conclusions from them than the rest of us (deranged space hippies). I simply could not imagine - and still cannot - how can one come to any other conclusion when even the mental apparatus which one uses to draw those f*cking conclusions is explained away by a meta-level which apparently uses said apparatus to manifest itself.

I have this secret hope that one day they will follow in the footsteps of bancopuma and find out what we mean by truly spiritual - or in gibran2's words: reality-confirming - experiences.


I originally had difficulty with this too so I understand how incredulous it seems, but I keep bringing it back to how this is entirely subjective. We don't need to prove our subjective experiences and try to convince others who draw a different interpretation. Anyone who asks for proof is missing the point that proof is not needed to validate a subjective thing.

Entering into dialogue about it in a mature manner is great, however when things start going south and ego starts creeping in and it becomes about defending one position over another, this just leads to headaches and gets us nowhere.
 
cellux said:
Citta and benzyme (and burnt) really gave me a headache :) when they claimed that they in fact HAD had these deep spiritual experiences, they just drew entirely different conclusions from them than the rest of us (deranged space hippies). I simply could not imagine - and still cannot - how can one come to any other conclusion when even the mental apparatus which one uses to draw those f*cking conclusions is explained away by a meta-level which apparently uses said apparatus to manifest itself.

I have this secret hope that one day they will follow in the footsteps of bancopuma and find out what we mean by truly spiritual - or in gibran2's words: reality-confirming - experiences.

Haha, hope that headache of yours ain't that bad!

We're scientists cellux, we're trained to question and be critical, we're trained to require or go look for evidence beyond our mere personal experiences, no matter how profound they are. They just don't cut it, and we just don't readily believe something just because we want to.

Let me draw an analogy to dreams; when you dream at night most of the times you have no idea that you are dreaming. This dream is evidently real, you think it's real. The people in it, the places, the events - they are all really happening. But when you wake up you suddenly realize that it was just a dream, and thus the content of the experience wasn't so real after all. I can only talk for myself, but I have had insane hallucinogenic trips before, and I took them at face value for several years. But then slowly I started questioning them. Slowly I learned more science, I started educating myself in science, and I became more critical. I read other plausible explanations. This is akin to you dreaming and taking it at face value, whereas upon waking up you probably start having doubts as to the reality of the content of that dream. Well, I started "waking" up from my mystical worldview and started having doubts after a few years.

We're just more skeptical than a lot of folks here I guess, and realize personal experiences are not cut to draw definite conclusions concerning deep questions about how reality works. As Richard Feynman once said "The first principle is that you must not fool yourself - and you are the easiest person to fool". This applies equally well to "reality-confirming" experiences, so we're just taking one step back to look at it from a distance so as to not fool ourselves into unfounded and unjustified beliefs on the basis of personal experiences (that can be the greatest of tricksters).
 
benzyme said:
tele said:
benzyme said:
those are the most obvious.

so how would you suggest a tree, or a mailbox, is conscious?

Who, Me? I haven't thought about it and don't know what to think about it completely, but:
Firstly mailbox and tree are completely different things(one is alive). Secondly, if something is alive doesn't it mean it almost has to have some kind of consciousness? Even if it's only code in it's structure that tells it to breathe(and grow etc basics). Maybe one way to look at it is that if it breathes, it is conscious?
ok, so how could you determine if coral is conscious?

to me, the definition of conscious is awareness of self and others.

I agree with this definition.

I think in the future when asking somones opinion on something THEIR definition should be noted. Other wise we keep defining things in our own way and never really come to an actual answer.

When you are unconscious you are not aware, of yourself or others. When you become conscious you are then aware. i apply this to defining things that are conscious.
 
jamie said:
yes it has been observed that certain area of the brain were less active..but that does not mean that other area are not more active then before..I am not saying the data that people have compiled is not valid-it is..but there is much we do not understand at this point about psychedelics and how they effect the nervous system.

Jamie, Prof Nutt said that Psilocybin actually shut down a part of the brain that is overstimulated in depressed people. I don't think he noticed that it actively engaged other parts of their brain. However that was just Psilocybin. Maybe more studies into the functioning of the brain will reveal more plausible explanations for elf visions to those that have participated in the spirit molecule.

Eliyahu said:
What I am suggesting is that the universe transforms itself according to the actions of each individual observer.

The spirit reveals itself and proves itself to a person in such a way that leaves no doubt of it's realness. By the same token it does it in just such a way that the person could never prove the realness to another. This way everyone has to experience the spirit world first hand and no one can ever just know that it exists without experiencing it themselves..

I dig this explanation, Eliyahu!

I think you have summed up the need for what Terence McKenna described as the "felt prescence of experience", or something. It's no good reading other peoples trip reports, yes they are interesting, but we are all on different paths and need to create our own experiences and not live off those of others!

Questioning visions of elves and jaguars might interest some, but might irritate others. What is interesting is how Ayahuasca can for example generate visions of such things in people in all parts of the world where there are no such creatures. Images of Anacondas in France or England..Why don't they see local creatures???... There's definately some plant intelligence going on there. Tarantulas, Boas, Anacondas, Jaguars, are animals from the Jungle. Seeing is believing as they say. Most of us believe in what we see, and some question, and some doubt. Such is human nature.

Each person must seek their own path in life, and hopefully they will recieve the knowledge that is for them. What they choose to do with that knowledge is for them to decide, and should not be left for others to interpret. I guess people need to have more trust in their mindsets.
 
This whole dark matter, collective unconscious, teeming nexus of human souls etc thing... It's just silly. People are going to chase fantastic explanations for their experience, they always have (every other mythology ever, etc.)... other people are going to try and shoot them down and say the experience is meaningless because it's so fantastical. C'est la vie. Personally this guy only bothers me as much as Strassman with his "dark matter" BS.

Besides, it's pretty friggin stupid to be arguing the technical points of a strong drug trip when we don't know ourselves, our minds and bodies, and the mechanisms behind such intense hallucination anyway. These are the things to look into before assuming anything on the subject of the validity of visions... otherwise you're just shooting in the ark and asking to be made a fool.

Furthermore... We all should damn well know what the real important stuff is here. Authors and Doctors chasing hallucinations like a bunch of Honeymooners just wastes time and effort... and makes us ALL look like a bunch of idiots arguing over how crazy we actually are.
 
Sigh....it depends who you're talking to, sometimes.

Once, I was talking with my girlfriend. Smart chick. She has a degree in science stuff. She gets going on quantum talk, and it's all cool and stuff, but it goes on for awhile. And the point she's driving to, oh golly, this ones going blow yer socks off fellas, get ready! It was some sort of quantum model, "proving" that everything is conscious. Or that consciousness is the fundemental state of stuff, like matter, energy, consciousness. You know the type of talk I mean.

Wowee zowee, I told her. Animism. You just spent like an hour describing...animism. Science is totally fun sometimes, but spare me the hours long rant to tell me nothing new. Yup, stuff is conscious. Shamans the world over have always said that.


My 2-bits. No offense intended towards other view points.

You know....I haven't read trialogues at the edge of the west since 1999 when I first got it, but I think it was that book where someone offered a definition of consciousness that I liked. Basically they said that a hallmark of consciousness would be chemical reactions going off. Stasis looks less conscious.

Then again, pluto may seem dead....but in the long run, it's a part of a much larger chemical proccess, our solar system.
 
Looking at this thread makes me sad. People are throwing bad things at each other, forgetting how to have a good debate, and somehow a lot of people also forget to keep their critical thinking alive.

I will keep this thread locked for now.


The Traveler
 
Back
Top Bottom