Citta said:
Stimulate the brain by physical means in the right ways and you get funny, reproducible shit happening that has no relevance at all to the external world, except perhaps for distorted signals and interpretations. The brain does not create perfect models of the world around it, it often fails actually. This, among other things, is why subjective events happening in the DMT-flooded, overstimulated brain is pretty dubious. There is, in short, currently not many credible reasons to assume anything extraordinary is going on when someone smokes DMT except for all or a combination of the following; distortion of the senses, imagination running wild, hallucinations, interpretation of abnormal biochemical interactions and stimulation coupled with our personal inner life and unconscious processes etc.
Note: The response here is a tad lengthy, but I encourage you - or anyone viewing this thread - to read the article excerpts provided below.
I agree with the first part of the above quote, but hold some reservations on the second part. There is, I believe, data from DMT experience that may indeed push us beyond mere neurochemical models (however not necessarily "physical" models). I will provide below two excerpts from two scholarly articles by psychologist and active researcher David Luke that I highly recommend should be read by anyone interested in the ontology of DMT experiences. The first is from "Discarnate Entities and Dimethyltrypamine", and the the second is from "Rock Art or Rorschach: Is there More to Entoptics than Meets the Eye?" Also highly recommended (and more mainstream) is:
Vollenweider, F.X., and Geyer, M.A., 2001. “A Systems Model of Altered Consciousness: Integrating Natural and Drug-induced Psychoses.” Brain Research Bulletin 56(5): 495–507.
"Vollenweider and Geyer (2001) have proposed that psychedelics both inhibit the 'gating' of extraneous sensory stimuli and simultaneously lead to an overload of internal information in the cortex. It is thought that these combined information-overload effects are at least partly responsible for the 'hallucinogenic' (a particularly laden medical term which obscures more than it reveals) experience with these drugs, as is indicated by an increased physiological startle response to incoming auditory stimuli (Vollenweider 2001). This disruption of
the sensory gating function by psychedelics could also underpin the neurochemistry of genuine psi experiences, which, like psychedelic experiences, are associated with the inhibition of ordinary sensory filtering, elevated creativity, boundary thinness, schizotypal symptoms, and self-expansiveness."
"Discarnate Entities and Dimethyltrypamine":
One alternative approach to investigating the ontology of shamanic entity encounters considers similarities in independent reports concerning the characteristics of particular entities, especially those encountered naively and without any cultural context from which the characteristics of the entity could be derived (Luke, 2008a). For instance, one such being that commonly appears to naïve DMT users is an entity consisting of multiple entwined serpents covered in multitudinous eyes, often forming a fibonacci-spiral-like geometrical shape. Obscure references to a similar mythological entity, sometimes identified as 'the angel of death', also exist in various cultural cosmologies, possibly indicating the trans-cultural nature of this entity (Luke, 2008a). Such data pose challenging questions as to whether the entity is culturally mediated— which seems unlikely given the obscurity of the cultural references — or a culture-free universal feature of DMT activation (naturally or artificially) in the brain, with possible incorporeal origins.
A similar phenomenological triangulation approach could fruitfully be made with other types of entities commonly encountered with DMT and ayahuasca, such as the bizarre preponderance of praying mantises (Luke, 2008b). It might be possible by such means to determine how statistically improbable is the occurrence of these shared visions. Such a methodology has its limitations, of course, nevertheless upon inspection of the literature it appears that such an approach has rarely been applied to the study of apparently collective visions and may point the baffled DMT ontologist in an enlightening direction.
"Rock Art or Rorschach: Is there More to Entoptics than Meets the Eye?":
My own experience consuming DMT- containing substances and mixtures has provided me with a host of geometric visual phenomena of such exquisite complexity, seeming impossibility, and baffling multidimensionality that it seems difficult to believe that “the patterns of connections between the retina and the striate cortex and of the neuronal circuits within the striate cortex determined their geometric form,” nor that “people [perceiving entopic phenomena following the ingestion of psychotropic substances] are seeing the structure of their own brain” (Lewis- Williams 2002: 126). The mescaline and perception researcher Smythies (1953: 346) had difficulty enough mapping the visual system to merely three-dimensional percepts: “how may these visions be related in their internal three-dimensional spatio-temporal structure to the electrical patterns in the cortex, which possesses an entirely different spatio-temporal structure determined by the complex convoluted shape of the cortex?” So how is it that a tangle of neurochemical “wiring” (a term used ad infinitum by Lewis-Williams) can be mapped to what the present author has perceived as a nonordinary extra-dimensional geometric vision? Approaching entoptic phenomena, then, from a first-hand phenomenological position there is good reason to agree with Shanon (2003: 6) about his observations from his own ayahuasca experiences when he further states that “to a great extent, most scientists ... who talk of hallucinations do not know what they are talking about and that, in fact, what they say is more a reflection of their conceptual presuppositions with regard to this subject matter than a fair characterization of the psychological phenomenology at hand.”
...
Multidimensional Form Constants
Following his experimentation with the psychedelic mescaline-containing cactus, peyote (Lophophora williamsii), Klüver (1926, 1966 [1928]) originally conceived form constants to fall into four different geometric categories: lattices, cobwebs, tunnels, and spirals. Later researchers used cocaine, LSD, and cannabis, as well as a variety of nondrug means of inducing geometric visual percepts (see Dronfield 1996) and they defined similar categorizations which Lewis-Williams and Dowson (1988) finally combined to make six entoptic forms: grids, lattices, dots, zigzag lines, nested curves, and filigrees. More recently Dronfield (1996) opted for seven. Renderings of these geometric percepts on paper obviously look two-dimensional, although from my own experience with mescaline-containing cacti such patterns are often perceived to fit the structure of objects in consensus reality and look three-dimensional. In relation to their own mescaline-induced percepts Klüver (1926: 505) concurred that “the designs [as on rugs] seem to be localized on walls, on the floor, etc.,” as did Smythies (1956: 81) who noted that the “hallucinations are spatial and coloured entities and may possess not only a high degree of internal organization, but may also be closely integrated into the ‘veridical’ remainder of the visual field in which they occur.”
On tryptamine-based psychedelics, such as DMT, such geometric patterns may take the same form (frequently hexagons in this author’s own experience) but, unlike mescaline visions, can assume extra- dimensional qualities the likes of which do not ordinarily occur in waking reality. One of the most prominent researchers writing on their own tryptamine experiences, McKenna (1991: 35), supports this assertion: “there is an immense vividness to these interior landscapes, as if information were being presented three-dimensionally and deployed fourth-dimensionally, coded as light and as evolving surfaces.”
...All of the examples above clearly establish that the geometric percepts seen in certain altered states, such as those induced by ayahuasca and DMT, may assume extraordinary dimensional qualities that are virtually ineffable and exceedingly difficult to render in static two-dimensional art...
Taking this observation a step further, it is suggested that these percepts therefore challenge the received wisdom that Klüver’s psychedelic form constants are actually entoptic, that is, derived from within the optic system somewhere from the eyeball to the cortex (e.g. Lewis- Williams and Dowson 1988). Not only is there the standard cognitive neuroscience miracle of electromagnetic impulses somehow becoming converted into the three-dimensional percepts of the outside world—a feat still not satisfactorily explained by neuroscientists or philosophers (see e.g. Velmans 2009)—but the mind is apparently also capable of multidimensional geometric perception beyond what is ordinarily perceived in the normal waking state.
Of course, much more needs be said, and such a topic probably requires its own separate thread anyway...