No...where did i say anything about the status of the DMT-experience? (except the statement that we cannot say anything about it with any certainty)I don´t give a fuck about what kent thinks btw. I´m just abstaining from a definitive judgement and staying on the cautious side when it comes to any claims about things we don´t know shit about.zapped17 said:polytrip said:zapped17:'I humbly point out that herein lies your error'
No, i´m not making a mistake: I never said anything about the status of DMT-experiences.
I simply applied the logic or occams razor, wich ofcourse proofs nothing...
And the brain IS capable of producing experiences that feel 'real' to the experiencer, without them actually being real. Anyone who has ever had a very vivid dream will immediately admit that.
Of course you said something about the ontological status of the DMT experiences. Thats kinda what this whole thread is about...
Your digression about the principle of Occam's Razor is a red herring. Did you consider what Kent said about the DMT experiences in the Q&A section of "The Case Against DMT Elves"? What would be your perspective on that - keeping the statement you made in your first post in mind?
"And the brain IS capable of producing experiences that feel 'real' to the experiencer,without them actually being real."
Yes, the as far as mainstream neuroscience is concerned, the brain mediates ALL experience, real or not. But now we have moved into the slippery topic of what is "real" and how do we know, or rather, what constitutes a veridical perception versus a falsidical perception? The problem here is we have no definite universally agreed upon concept of what is "real". But since this thread pertains on Kent's article, let's narrowing down the discussion again and consider his view. As I quoted previously, Kent:
"...[considers] the entities simply as information generators. For Kent (2010), the question of the entities' reality is redundant given that they generate real information, and sometimes this seems to go beyond the experient's available sphere of knowledge." According to Kent, the elves are non-sentient archetypal interfaces of our collective unconscious.
As I said, I think this is a decent explanation, given the data (see my response to "citta" somewhere below/above). Simply (dogmatically) asserting that "its all a hallucination because you can stimulate the brain into producing various sensations" has ZERO explanatory power. Explaining exactly HOW these particular DMT induced experiences are reducible to neurochemical reactions - i.e., entopic hallucinations - extends itself way beyond the current explanatory capabilities of neuroscience. It's possible that such a reductive explanation of the data cannot be given in principle, and only correlations can be drawn (which is all we have atm).
I think it´s just wise to be cautious: we expect pharmaceutical company´s to be cautious with claims about a new drug, untill it´s been properly tested on humans, we expect world leaders to be cautious when making claims about weapons of mass destruction in iraq, etc.
So why not stick to those high principles ourselves?
What irritates me, and that may be the cause of why you think i´m being a sceptic here, is when people say that anyone who doesn´t blindly belief in something he experiences on a powerfull HALLUCINOGENIC drug is some left-brain fascist who wants to rob the world from it´s beauty and who wants to trivialise your experience or, well...your very life itself.
To reject criticism towards things experienced in a dream or during a psychedelic session, to reject criticism towards any random speculation about 'reality' is just a bit narcissistic.
When people get angry about science because it seems to contradict one of their own personal random speculations about the nature of the universe, when they even accuse science of being totalitarian and imperialistic because of this, while at least the scientist tries hard to see if he can falsify what he´s been working on for years..in other words: when people freely speculate about something like the nature of the universe and get angry when real and proper investigation doesn´t immediately seem to back-up the claims subsequently made...it´s not even a bit narcissistic. It´s VERY narcissistic. It´s like believing you are god, the center of the universe. Like your own, very personal belief would make it real.
Criticism is good. It´s the motor behind any real form of personal growth. Any lack of it is just lazynes.
That's why I seriously question both the ontology of dmt elves AS WELL AS the explanatory power of mere neuroscientific explanations (or lack thereof) for certain phenomena - of course, only when the data/evidence compels me to. That's also precisely why a criticized your initial assertion, and James Kent's article. If I didn't do so, this discourse would not be happening.