explain how a tree is conscious
You want evidence, not the truth.benzyme said:murphythecat said:..the consciousness is not created by our brain.
where's your evidence of this?
it's easy to make grandiose, anecdotal claims based on altered states of mind; now show some evidence that the mind exists independently from the brain.
Are you serious?benzyme said:explain how a tree is conscious

gosh I dont even know what you want from this discussion.benzyme said:hey, I happen to like superstition. it shows us how far we've come from believing the world is flat.
Explain how a human being is conscious.benzyme said:explain how a tree is conscious
gibran2 said:Explain how a human being is conscious.benzyme said:explain how a tree is conscious
benzyme said:gibran2 said:Explain how a human being is conscious.benzyme said:explain how a tree is conscious
define: emotions; instint. action/reaction
men, I'm sending you as much love to you as I can. I still think that you are a valuable member here for multiple reasons. I understand your point of vue, I once thought like you. All I really want is to help you and clearly, you seem to want to be the smart ass here.benzyme said:you're worried?
because I can differentiate between animate and inanimate? wow. maybe I should see a shrink.
*questions everything he's ever been taught and experienced*
murphythecat said:men, I'm sending you as much love to you as I can. I still think that you are a valuable member here for multiple reasons. I understand your point of vue, I once thought like you. All I really want is to help you and clearly, you seem to want to be the smart ass here.benzyme said:you're worried?
because I can differentiate between animate and inanimate? wow. maybe I should see a shrink.
*questions everything he's ever been taught and experienced*
I love you anyways men, I'm only worried that you dont, and it would be sad.
murphythecat said:men, I'm sending you as much love to you as I can. I still think that you are a valuable member here for multiple reasons. I understand your point of vue, I once thought like you. All I really want is to help you and clearly, you seem to want to be the smart ass here.benzyme said:you're worried?
because I can differentiate between animate and inanimate? wow. maybe I should see a shrink.
*questions everything he's ever been taught and experienced*
I love you anyways men, I'm only worried that you dont, and it would be sad.
benzyme said:those are the most obvious.
so how would you suggest a tree, or a mailbox, is conscious?
christian said:jamie said:We know that there are parts of the brain that when activated can produce experiences like seeing ghosts.
All we know is that certain areas of the brain are active when we have these experiences, and that they play some role
Really??
Prfessor David Nutt has stated that Psilocybin , for example, shuts down the reasoning parts of the brain, which is why people experience the "visions". The de-activation is responsible. This would explain that the brain is a kinda filter to protect the ego from information overload.
PERHAPS and ego can only exist with a limited amount of information? Maybe when DMT destroys the ego, entities are there to offer some kinda psychic cushioning and assistence to what awaits the traveller?
damn, this is too much for me.Citta said:murphythecat said:men, I'm sending you as much love to you as I can. I still think that you are a valuable member here for multiple reasons. I understand your point of vue, I once thought like you. All I really want is to help you and clearly, you seem to want to be the smart ass here.benzyme said:you're worried?
because I can differentiate between animate and inanimate? wow. maybe I should see a shrink.
*questions everything he's ever been taught and experienced*
I love you anyways men, I'm only worried that you dont, and it would be sad.
You are acting like the smartass, the O' so Wise Man that has the answers, and sees that poor benzyme here have lost his soul, lost his love, is unhappy, doesn't love himself, hates the world and have serious issues because he remains rational, skeptical and scientific concerning questions about how the universe works. Drop it.
ok, so how could you determine if coral is conscious?tele said:benzyme said:those are the most obvious.
so how would you suggest a tree, or a mailbox, is conscious?
Who, Me? I haven't thought about it and don't know what to think about it completely, but:
Firstly mailbox and tree are completely different things(one is alive). Secondly, if something is alive doesn't it mean it almost has to have some kind of consciousness? Even if it's only code in it's structure that tells it to breathe(and grow etc basics). Maybe one way to look at it is that if it breathes, it is conscious?
Tek said:We should stop trying to argue this point. Subjective experience is exactly that; subjective. Nothing can be proven in this regard, but if you REALLY get it, you know you don't NEED to prove it. The experience is enough to convince certain people, others not so much.
when they claimed that they in fact HAD had these deep spiritual experiences, they just drew entirely different conclusions from them than the rest of us (deranged space hippies). I simply could not imagine - and still cannot - how can one come to any other conclusion when even the mental apparatus which one uses to draw those f*cking conclusions is explained away by a meta-level which apparently uses said apparatus to manifest itself.